Home Blog Page 5316

PDEA agents, cops face homicide and assault raps on raid

PHILIPPINE STAR/ MICHAEL VARCAS

GOVERNMENT prosecutors have endorsed the indictment of three agents of the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency (PDEA) and four police officers over the botched buy-bust operations in Quezon City last year, where four law enforcers were killed.

In a statement dated May 17 and sent to reporters on Thursday, the Department of Justice (DoJ) said the agents would be charged with homicide for the death of a police officer. The police officers would face direct assault charges for mauling several PDEA agents.

On Feb. 24, last year, PDEA and the police separately held buy-bust operations along Commonwealth Avenue in Quezon City when a shootout between law enforcers took place. Two policemen, a PDEA agent and an informant died.

“After an evaluation of the evidence, the panel of prosecutors found sufficient evidence to charge [the PDEA agents] with homicide for the death of a police officer,” DoJ said in the statement. “There is also probable cause to charge some police officers for direct assault due to the injuries sustained by the PDEA responders.”

Prosecutors also dismissed two homicide complaints for the death of another cop and a PDEA agent for lack of evidence.

Philippine prosecutors have filed charges in court against law enforcers in four cases and plan to probe 250 more of what could have been wrongful deaths in Mr. Duterte’s drug war, Justice Secretary Menardo I. Guevarra told the United Nations Human Rights Council in February.

An inter-agency committee formed 15 teams last year that probed extralegal killings and human rights violations involving the government’s anti-illegal drug operations.

The Justice department on Tuesday dropped 29 cases from its list of extralegal killings and torture cases for lack of evidence.

The cases involved witnesses that could not be found or complainants who decided not to pursue their complaints, Mr. Guevarra told reporters in a Viber message.

Meanwhile, the Commission on Human Rights (CHR) scored the Duterte government for encouraging a culture of impunity by hindering independent inquiries and failing to prosecute erring cops involved in the deadly drug war.

Internal investigations of anti-drug operations that led to deaths have been “inaccessible and nontransparent,” it said in a 48-page report.

Survivors of Mr. Duterte’s war on drugs found it difficult to pursue justice despite overwhelming evidence because the state refused to cooperate with independent probers, the human rights body said.

Police have “refused, denied or ignored” subpoenas and requests from the commission to review police documents even if they followed guidelines to obtain the information, according to the report.

“Independent and impartial accountability mechanisms, such as the fact-finding investigations by the CHR, have been hampered by the predilection and uncooperativeness of agencies involved in the campaign against illegal drugs.”

Authorities have cited a 2017 order from Mr. Duterte “not to participate in any investigation into alleged human rights violations committed by its agents without his clearance,” the agency said.

The CHR report presented 882 drug-related cases involving 1,139 victims, or 23% of the 3,790 drug-related killings examined by the commission from 2016 to 2021. Of the total, 2,305 investigations were finished.

Police had used “excessive and disproportionate force” in most of the drug raids, contrary to their self-defense claims, it said. It added that 73% of  511 victims who had allegedly resisted arrest were killed by gunshots to the head and torso.

These indicated “intent to kill by the police operatives and disproportionality of force used to repel aggression,” CHR said.

It urged police to conduct “full, immediate, transparent and impartial investigations on drug-related extra-judicial killings.”

The Justice department should also investigate the cases related to the deadly drug war through the National Bureau of Investigation and “prosecute persons charged with the commission of these extrajudicial killings through the National Prosecution Service.”

The agency said DoJ should also regularly and automatically furnish the human rights body with “complete and comprehensive reports” on the cases.

The latest report was among the last CHR assessments on the Duterte government’s war on drugs. The terms of the agency’s head and four other commissioners ended on May 5. — John Victor D. Ordoñez and Kyle Aristophere T. Atienza

Incoming House members eye barangay elections postponement to save funds for COVID response 

HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

LEYTE Rep. Martin G. Romualdez, who has been reelected and is poised to assume the House speakership in the next Congress, said his colleagues are looking at proposals to postpone the barangay elections in December to save funds that could be used for the countrys pandemic response.   

We will have savings of P8.141 billion that we can use for COVID-19 response and economic stimulus such as ayuda (cash aid),he told reporters in mixed English and Filipino after meeting his allies in a luxurious hotel on Thursday, based on a video shared by his camp.   

The next Congress is already eyeing the passage of a pandemic response legislation that would be named after the famous initials of presumptive president Ferdinand BongbongR. Marcos, Jr.  

“It will allow the incoming president to harness the resources available during the closing period of 2022 and pass measures that are needed for the pandemic, hopefully endemic stage of this COVID,” Mr. Romualdez said.   

The solon, cousin of Mr. Marcos, said village officials had been asking them to postpone the democratic practice that could possibly replace those who would seek reelection.  

A barangay is the smallest political unit in the Philippines and its officials are deemed as governments frontline leaders.   

We shall consider [their proposal],said Mr. Romualdez, noting that the proposal would likely be among the priority items of the next Congress.  

Present at Thursdays meeting were PDP-Laban president and Energy Secretary Alfonso G. Cusi and Benjamin “Benhur” Abalos, Jr., who has been tapped by Mr. Marcos, Jr. to lead the Interior department.  

This is the message of unity, and this is whats happening at the House of Representatives,he said of the emerging coalition, which academics say is a coalition of influential clans in the country.  

Mr. Marcos campaigned on a general platform of unity and his tandem with presumptive vice president Sara Duterte-Carpio, daughter of the incumbent president, was labeled as the Uniteam

Mr. Romualdez has been meeting with known powerbrokers in Philippine politics and members of the incoming Congress. 

House Speaker Lord Allan Q. Velasco and former President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo, who will be taking a seat in the incoming Congress as representative of her home province Pampanga, have already endorsed his speakership bid. Kyle Aristophere T. Atienza 

Senator-elect Tulfo eyes changes in rules to carry over bills from previous Congress 

SENATE.GOV.PH

SENATOR-ELECT Rafael T. Tulfo will be proposing adjustments in rules to allow the new Congress to take up bills deemed important from where the previous legislature left off.   

Perhaps a few changes to the rules of both chambers can make this happen,Mr. Tulfo said in a statement released late Wednesday after he and the 11 other new senators were officially proclaimed by the Commission on Elections.  

I see several worthy bills which have gone through hundreds, thousands of man-hours of work. It would be a pity if those worthy bills will just go straight to the archives of Congress just because the 18th Congress ends,he said.  

By worthy bills, he meant proposed laws that have at least been approved at the committee level.  

I will therefore ask the current Senate leadership and my colleagues in the incoming 19th Congress to find ways to preserve the bills by keeping them alive, returning them to the committees they came from so that the members of the 19th Congress can build upon those bills with inputs from the new members of Congress,he said.  

Mr. Tulfo earlier said that he will prioritize legislation relating to labor issues.  

The current Congress will resume sessions on May 24 and adjourn on June 3, leaving only two weeks for lawmakers to pass bills and canvass votes for president and vice president.  

DEEMED DEAD
Senate President Vicente C. Sotto III said Mr. Tulfos plan is unlikely to happen, but bills that will be refiled in the 19th Congress can always use previous discussions as reference.   

All bills and resolutions filed are deemed dead after June 3 adjournment sine die,he said.   

What he (Mr. Tulfo) wants is easy to solve without violating laws and traditions. Refile, then those in advance stages can use the previous hearings and debates as references.” 

The senate chief has said that the upper chamber plans to pass bills on second and third reading during its six remaining plenary sessions.  

However, for all other bills that are not in their advanced stages, it is no longer possible, he added.  

Members from both chambers of Congress are expected to meet next week in a joint session at the House of Representatives to form the National Board of Canvassers.  

Mr. Sotto said they will work continuously to finish the canvassing of votes for president and vice president on time.  

If we start on (the) 24th, non-stop, we can finish by the 26th,he said. The practice or tradition is that proclamation follows immediately after.” 

Mr. Sotto and House Speaker Lord Allan Jay Q. Velasco will spearhead the canvassing of votes. Their goal is to proclaim the countrys two top leaders by May 28 at the latest.  

Canvassers need to “ensure that the canvassing of votes cast and proclamation of the countrys next two highest officials will be seamless and the integrity of the electoral process is upheld,said Mr. Velasco in a statement on Wednesday.  

The Senate has received 88% or 153 of 173 election certificates and returns for president and vice-president as of Thursday morning, it said in a statement.  

It took delivery of local certificates and returns from Sulu and overseas absentee voting certificates from the United States of America and Australia.  

Newly-appointed leaders of the country will assume office at noon on June 30. Alyssa Nicole O. Tan 

Duterte appoints new appellate court members 

PHILSTAR FILE PHOTO

PRESIDENT Rodrigo R. Duterte has named two new members of the Court of Appeals, his office announced on Thursday.   

In a statement, Palace Spokesman Jose Ruperto Martin M. Andanar said Mr. Duterte has appointed John Zurbito Lee and Eleuterio Larisma Bathan as new associate justices of the appellate court.  

The two new members of the countrys second highest tribunal will replace Japar Dimaampao, who was appointed as an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court, and Dorothy Montejo-Gonzaga, who resigned last year. 

Prior to their new appointments, Ms. Bathan served at the Quezon City Regional Trial Court, while Mr. Lee became a managing partner of a private law firm where he handled taxation law, estate planning, corporate law,among others.  

Mr. Lee had also joined another private law firm that was co-founded by Louise LizaC. Araneta Marcos, wife of presumptive president Ferdinand BongbongR. Marcos, Jr. Kyle Aristophere T. Atienza 

Bangsamoro business council to help attract more investments in Cotabato City

@BANGSAMOROGOVT

THE BUSINESS sector in the Bangsamoro region in southern Philippines is mobilizing a multi-sectoral campaign to attract more investors in Cotabato City and build up on the local economys growth momentum last year.   

The Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (BARMM) Business Council met earlier this week with members of civil society organizations, business groups, and academic institutions to discuss opportunities in the city, the regions political and commercial center.   

Ronald Hallid Torres, the business councils chair, rallied stakeholders to work as one to sustain BARMMs economic development.  

BCC recognized that our business sector is doing very well. To all interested investors, this is the best time for you to come and we will work hard to ensure that we can work together here in Cotabato City,Mr. Torres is quoted as saying in a statement released by the BARMM government.  

The council is a region-wide group composed of directors from provincial business chambers. Its creation in October 2021 was facilitated by the BARMM Ministry of Trade, Investments and Tourism (MTIT).  

MTIT Director-General Rosslaini Alonto-Sinarimbo underscored that the business sector is the backbone of the economy.”  

They are the ones who pay taxes, can employ our constituents, and regenerate the structure and condition of our economy,she said. 

BARMMs economic performance grew by 7.5% last year after decelerating by 1.9% in 2020, based on Philippine Statistics Authority data released in April.   

All industries in the region saw positive growth in 2021, led by Human Health and Social Work Activities at 22.2%; Mining and Quarrying, 20.2%; Accommodation and Food Service Activities, 17.9%; Construction 12.2%; and Financial and Insurance activities, 10.6%.  

Bangsamoro Planning and Development Authority Director General Mohajirin T. Ali said the regions 2021 economic performance showed that BARMMwith its ongoing transition phase towards wider autonomy affected by the coronavirus pandemic has kept on track in fostering its concerted economic recovery efforts.”     

This demonstrates again that we are now waving the dividend of peace and we must keep the momentum as we are going for the BARMM advancement program, aimed at accelerating the socio-economic recovery and sustaining progress towards poverty reduction and economic growth,Mr. Ali said during the April 28 release of gross regional domestic product data.     

BARMM Chief Minister Ahod B. Ebrahim, for his part, said the regions economic performance reflects the Bangsamoro peoples determination and ability to adapt despite a health crisis.  

The economic data shows our shared work not just as the regional government but as one community,he said.   

Cotabato Citys incoming set of local government officials are led by members of the United Bangsamoro Justice Party of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF), which is at the forefront of the Bangsamoro transition.    

Mayor-elect Bruce D. Matabalao and Vice Mayor-elect Johari C. Abu, both of the MILF political party, were proclaimed last week.   

They defeated the tandem of Mayor Cynthia Guiani-Sayadi and Vice Mayor Graham G. Dumama, who were opposed to the inclusion of Cotabato City in the BARMM. MSJ 

Election returns

PHILIPPINE STAR/KRIZ JOHN ROSALES

BALLOT boxes containing election certificates and returns for president and vice president are kept at a guarded area in the Senate building. The Senate said on Thursday that it has so far received 88% or 153 of 173 election certificates and returns.

Warriors slow Luka Dončić, rout Mavs in Game 1

STEPHEN Curry led a high-percentage attack with 21 points and the Golden State Warriors dominated the visiting Dallas Mavericks on both ends of the floor en route to a 112-87 victory on Wednesday in Game 1 of the Western Conference finals in San Francisco.

Mavericks star Luka Dončić, coming off a 35-point, 12-for-19 shooting game in Dallas’ elimination of the top-seeded Phoenix Suns on Sunday, was harassed into just six-for-18 shooting and a playoffs season-low 20 points.

Dallas dropped Game 1 in its third consecutive series.

Game 2 in the best-of-seven set is scheduled for Friday in San Francisco, where Golden State, seeking its sixth trip to the NBA Finals in the past eight years, has gone 7-0 this postseason.

Taking advantage of the Mavericks’ poor shooting — Dallas finished the game at 36% — the Warriors never trailed over the final 45 minutes while taking a 1-0 lead for the third consecutive time this postseason.

All seven Warriors who played at least 13 minutes scored in double figures, with Curry getting plenty of help. Andrew Wiggins and Jordan Poole contributed 19 points apiece, Klay Thompson had 15 and Kevon Looney, Draymond Green and Otto Porter Jr. each had 10.

Golden State shot 56.1% from the field, led by Looney’s 5-for-5, Porter’s 5-for-7 and Poole’s 8-for-12.

Neither team shot well from 3-point range, but the Warriors shot far fewer. They made 10 of 29 (34.5%), while the Mavericks jacked up 48, making 11 (22.9%).

Curry and Wiggins nailed three treys apiece, with Curry also finding time for a game-high 12 rebounds and the game’s only double-double.

Green grabbed nine rebounds.

Wiggins played as big a role on the defensive end as on offense, blanketing Dončić most of the night and holding him four points below his previous low this postseason, that coming in Game 6 against the Utah Jazz in the first round. Dončić had at least 26 points in each of the seven games in the Phoenix series.

Dončić went just 3-for-10 on 3-point attempts, as did teammate Reggie Bullock, who finished with 12 points.

Spencer Dinwiddie had 17 points off the bench and Jalen Brunson scored 14 for the Mavericks, lost their first three road games of the Phoenix series by an average of 19 points before stunning the defending Western Conference champs in Game 7 on Sunday. — Reuters

Alcaraz threatens to gatecrash Djokovic and Nadal party in Paris

RECORD champion Rafael Nadal is locked in an all-time Grand Slam battle with world number one Novak Djokovic going into the French Open but both could end up being upstaged by teenage sensation Carlos Alcaraz.

Nadal, a 13-time title-winner on the Parisian red clay, is far from his unstoppable best as he nurses a chronic foot injury that flared up again in the buildup to Roland Garros.

The Australian Open champion suffered early exits in Madrid and Rome with his most recent tournament win back in February.

Counting out the wounded 35-year-old Spaniard, however, comes with a risk warning as his comeback win from two sets down over Russia’s Daniil Medvedev at this year’s Australian Open final proved.

Nadal’s astounding triumph meant he became the first male player to reach 21 Grand Slam titles, pulling ahead of Roger Federer and Djokovic on the all-time list.

Djokovic, who had missed the Australian Open following his refusal to be vaccinated for coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) and his subsequent deportation amid a media frenzy, is desperate to win in Paris and pull level with Nadal’s major haul.

The Serb, who also turns 35 later this week, appears to be back on track after his turbulent start to the year, clinching the title in Rome last week with a straight sets win over Greek world number four Stefanos Tsitsipas.

Djokovic is also no stranger to comebacks on the big stage, winning the title in Paris last year after battling from two sets down to outlast Tsitsipas.

The Greek, who thrives on this surface having won his last three titles on clay, has long been tipped as a Grand Slam winner and came agonisingly close last year.

But he will also be looking over his shoulder at the 19-year-old Alcaraz who looks set to jump the queue.

The teenager has taken the tennis world by storm this year with four titles, including in Miami and Madrid, and will arrive in Paris established as one of the title favorites.

The big-smiling Spaniard, a qualifier only 12 months ago, may look stunned by his progress this year but he shows no signs or interest of slowing down as he storms up the world rankings.

“Yes, I am ready to win a Grand Slam and to go for it,” the world number six said, who beat both Nadal and Djokovic en route to the Madrid title earlier in May.

“It is a goal for me this year, to try to get my first Grand Slam. Let’s see what is going to happen at Roland Garros.” — Reuters

NBA announces All-Rookie first, second teams

SCOTTIE Barnes of the Toronto Raptors, Cade Cunningham of the Detroit Pistons and Evan Mobley of the Cleveland Cavaliers each were unanimous selections for the National Basketball Association (NBA) All-Rookie first team announced on Wednesday.

Barnes, Cunningham and Mobley each received the maximum total of 200 points for the first team. Franz Wagner of the Orlando Magic (183 points) and Jalen Green of the Houston Rockets (158 points) also made the first team.

The NBA All-Rookie second team included Herbert Jones of the New Orleans Pelicans (123 points), Josh Giddey of the Oklahoma City Thunder (122 points), Bones Hyland of the Denver Nuggets (81 points), Ayo Dosunmu of the Chicago Bulls (75 points) and Chris Duarte of the Indiana Pacers (52 points).

The first-team announcement was the latest honor in a standout season for Barnes, who was named NBA Rookie of the Year earlier this month. He finished the season with 15.3 points, 7.5 rebounds and 3.5 assists per game.

Cunningham led all rookies with 17.4 points per game. Mobley pulled down 8.3 rebounds per game, which led the rookie class.

Jonathan Kuminga of the Golden State Warriors tallied 47 points, just shy of Duarte for the final spot on the second team. — Reuters

Remaining PHL bets in SEAG urged not to let health guards down

HANOI — National team chef de mission Ramon Fernandez on Thursday urged the county’s remaining campaigners in the 31st Vietnam Southeast Asian Games (SEAG) not to let their health and safety guards down as the sportsfest enters its critical homestretch.

“I urge our remaining athletes to remain vigilant and not be complacent with regards to the health and safety protocols they must follow to compete in the Vietnam SEA Games. They cannot let their guards down,” said Mr. Fernandez.

“Let not all of their hard work, sacrifice, time and effort go to waste. They trained intensively and came here to compete and not wind up as mere tourists,” the Philippine delegation point man stressed. He was grateful that there have been no reports of athletes and coaches testing positive for coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) since the action in the 31st edition of the regional meet went full blast six days ago.

As a standard procedure, athletes and coaches are required to take antigen tests for the virus a day before their performances so they can participate in their respective events once the results show they are negative, according to Mr. Fernandez.

He said that the contributions of the remaining athletes were important in fueling the Philippine drive to hit the target of finishing third overall in the medal standings with hostilities winding up on Sunday.

Despite a paltry four-gold haul last Tuesday, the Filipino bets clung to third spot with 38 golds, 50 silvers and 66 bronzes.

“But if any of our remaining national athletes, especially our top medal prospects, test positive, how can they contribute to the country’s cause? Sayang naman ang pagpunta nila rito,” Mr. Fernandez, a commissioner of the Philippine Sports Commission (PSC), noted.

Meanwhile, he announced that he issued a memo to the entire Philippine delegation last Monday on the health and safety protocols for the SEA Games participants whose events are over and returning to the country.

The PSC official said that athletes and coaches are required to take antigen tests 24 hours and, in special cases, to undergo swab tests 48 hours before returning to Manila.

“The tests are for free and will be conducted by a medical group at the assigned hotels of our Philippine delegation,” he said, adding that the delegates need to show a certificate of the test results upon their arrival in Manila.

Stealing home edge

The Celtics have remained confident in the aftermath of their disappointing loss in Game One of the Eastern Conference Finals the other day, and with reason. It isn’t simply because they won three of the four quarters they played against the Heat. In larger measure, it’s because head coach Ime Udoka has proven to be a master at making in-series adjustments, providing his charges with the impetus to quickly bounce back. Not for nothing are they three and zero in the 2022 postseason when it comes to outings immediately following a setback.

The Heat are, of course, motivated to achieve, with chief bench tactician Erik Spoelstra arguably even better than Udoka with a clipboard in hand. For the most part, though, the Celtics know they have the superior personnel, not to mention the best player in the seven-game affair. For all the consistency six-time All-Star Jimmy Butler has displayed in the playoffs to date, they know top dog Jayson Tatum is more talented and skilled, as evidenced by his performances against the Nets and Bucks (starring former Most Valuable Player awardees Kevin Durant and Giannis Antetokounmpo, respectively, in the previous rounds.

Not that the Celtics already have today’s set-to in hand. As their poor performance in the third period of Game One showed, they tend to be their own worst enemies. Tatum himself appears to lose focus at times. Remember his atrocious effort in Game Three of the semifinal-round series versus the Bucks? That said, they benefit from having short memories, hence their capacity to keep their Hyde side in check while bent on proving true to potential. And, certainly, the fact that they’ll have Defensive Player of the Year awardee Marcus Smart back in uniform should serve them in good stead.

True, the Celtics will remain handicapped with Al Horford sidelined due to health and safety protocols. On the other hand, Smart’s return from a foot injury addresses the biggest problem they faced in the opener; sophomore Payton Pritchard had no business logging 30 minutes and putting up a whopping 16 shots, and then serving as Butler’s punching bag at the other end of the floor. Bottom line, they know all the Heat did was hold court. They still have the opportunity to steal homecourt advantage, and they would do well to avail of it.

 

Anthony L. Cuaycong has been writing Courtside since BusinessWorld introduced a Sports section in 1994. He is a consultant on strategic planning, operations and Human Resources management, corporate communications, and business development.

Remembering the past

In addition to reports on Election Day events, some media organizations also try to explain the results of every election. They interview the responsible members of election watch groups, political scientists and other academics, and, if some issues whether legal or otherwise have arisen, lawyers and other professionals.

The May 9 election was no exception. But there was a difference in the intensity and range of media coverage of the most important electoral exercise in this country since the “snap elections” of 1986, and in the apprehensions among some journalists over the results of the exercise, among them the possibility that the current threats to press freedom could become even worse, and even a reprise in the years, months, or even weeks ahead of the suppression of free expression, press freedom, and other rights that was among the hallmarks of the Marcos Senior dictatorship.

The major TV networks had gone all out with hours of coverage that began in the early hours of Election Day with reportage on the initial turnout of voters, which candidates were voting, or had voted, and where. As the day wore on, they noted the delays caused by malfunctioning vote counting machines, and reported calls from some voters that voting hours be extended beyond 7 p.m. Later in the evening they began airing the early numbers in the race for President and Vice-President. It was the kind of attention that the occasion demanded. Many journalists apparently had the past in mind, and understood how important this year’s election is to the future of their country.

Print media, television, and radio had religiously reported the results of various surveys, which had uniformly found that Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos, Jr. would prevail over Vice-President Maria Leonor “Leni” Robredo. But some television anchors and reporters seemed surprised and even shocked over the numbers’ confirmation of the predictions of the public opinion polling firms.

The shock was most likely due to concerns that Marcos Junior, like his father, would be even more hostile to press freedom and the media than outgoing President Rodrigo Duterte. They were not only familiar with an incident during one of Marcos Junior’s rallies when Rappler reporter Lian Buan was prevented by his security personnel from getting closer to where the candidate was speaking, and was even pushed and injured by the same hirelings. Several broadcast reporters and their colleagues in other media platforms had also failed to get Marcos to answer even the simplest questions, let alone interview him during the campaign period. Some reports also recalled how Marcos had refused to participate in Presidential debates, forums, and panel discussions, and his spokesperson’s speaking for him at every turn. Both instances raised the question of how transparent a Marcos II administration would be, and if it would respect the people’s right to know and the media’s providing them with information on what government is doing.

The disturbing context of all this was their recollection of how media organizations were shut down or closely regulated and censored, and the targeted publishers, editors, and journalists were arbitrarily arrested, detained without charges, tortured, abducted and forcibly disappeared during the Marcos Senior dictatorship.

Their apprehensions were seemingly confirmed by another incident on May 11 — two days after Election Day — when Marcos’ spokesperson totally refused to answer, during a press conference he had called, the questions of, and ignored Rappler’s Lian Buan in a gross display of incivility and contempt for the press. Several media organizations reported the snub, to which the National Union of Journalists of the Philippines (NUJP) reacted by warning that it was a “red flag for press freedom” — that it could be an omen of things to come: of the possibility of that freedom’s being curtailed during a Marcos II regime in the same way that, as some of those who reported the incident recalled, the Marcos Senior dictatorship shut down media organizations whose reporting and analysis of public events and issues it did not like, and censored those it allowed to operate.

The media’s concerns were equally evident in other ways. They interviewed academics and experts in their quest for an explanation of how what had apparently been unthinkable to some journalists despite what the surveys said could still happen. A mere 36 years have passed since the EDSA civilian-military mutiny of 1986 overthrew the dictatorship and restored the institutions of liberal democracy, among them the very electoral process that, ironically, has very likely returned the Marcoses to the pinnacles of power.

Most of the experts attributed this paradox to, among other factors, the disinformation the troll farms have been spreading, and the failure of what passes for democracy in these isles to address the poverty and injustice that define the lives of millions of Filipinos, which has made authoritarian rule attractive to the poorest and most desperate.

But there are other factors as well that have nothing to do with either. There is the social media depiction of Marcos, despite the billions at his disposal, as the underdog and victim of unfair criticism and smear tactics, which must surely rank among the most successful public relations achievements in the world since Adolf Hitler’s demonization of European Jewry both before and during his rule in Germany.

There are also the allegations of vote-buying, the questions over Commission on Elections (Comelec) independence and non-partisanship, the impact of the Iglesia Ni Cristo (INC) endorsement of the Marcos-Duterte team, and the absence of a Catholic vote. (The Catholic masses apparently ignored the Church’s declaration of support for VP Robredo and Senator Francisco Pangilinan.)

Only in social media, however, were such issues as the following raised: 1.) The near incredible speed with which, shortly after the precincts closed, a trend indicating a Marcos-Duterte victory had already been established; and, 2.) VP Robredo’s 14 million-plus votes’ being almost the same as her numbers in 2016 when she won the Vice-Presidency over Marcos.

In any case, the silver lining in the aftermath of May 9 is the seeming awakening of much of the media — this early and more than a month before Marcos Junior is inaugurated — to the need for militancy in monitoring an incoming administration that even earlier had demonstrated its antagonism to transparency. It had refused to make known to the public its program of government, and throughout the campaign was unwilling to answer even the easiest questions the press was asking, let alone the hard ones that every responsible journalist is duty-bound to ask in behalf of the public’s right to information.

Equally important, however, is the attainment of media unity in the defense and enhancement of press freedom, to which journalists and their organizations must be committed. The different and even conflicting political and economic interests of corporate media have made achieving that unity problematic. But press freedom is surely in everyone’s interest.

Beyond self-interest, however, what is at stake is press freedom’s being indivisibly part of the conditions needed in resuming the democratization process that the Duterte regime so brazenly suppressed, and of journalists’ being true to the duty of resisting the tyranny that, as the Marcos Senior dictatorship so clearly demonstrated, would make the press, and with it the people’s right to know, among its first victims.

Never have the lessons of the past been as clearly and as urgently relevant than today. As the troubled history of this country of forgetfulness reminds us all, it is often necessary to remember what has gone before in order to prevent its repetition.

 

Luis V. Teodoro is on Facebook and Twitter (@luisteodoro).

www.luisteodoro.com