Home Blog Page 10697

Jollibee’s overseas push may cost stock’s premium valuation

JOLLIBEE Foods Corp. is buying coffee chain Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf. — CATHY ROSE A. GARCIA

JOLLIBEE Foods Corp., one of the most expensive Philippine stocks, could see its premium valuation deteriorate as the Manila-based restaurant operator pursues overseas expansion to cut its reliance at home.

Jollibee’s push abroad will dilute its Philippine story that persuaded many investors to pay a premium for the stock, according to analysts including Andy dela Cruz and Rachelle Cruz at COL Financial Group, Inc. and AP Securities, Inc. The company, the most expensive in the Philippine Stock Exchange index after Universal Robina Corp., is moving closer to its goal of getting half its sales from abroad with its purchase of Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf.

Jollibee, which started as an ice cream parlor in 1975, has beaten McDonald’s Corp. in the Philippines, one of the few markets the US fastfood giant has failed to dominate. Coffee Bean will raise the overseas component of Jollibee’s sales to 36% from 20% in 2018, according to the company, which has a presence in 18 markets outside the Philippines through a mix of homegrown brands and overseas acquisitions.

“This could trigger a downward re-rating for the stock,” AP Securities’ Ms. Cruz said. “Its aggressive push outside could be a signal its home market is getting saturated. And if you valued Jollibee for its Philippine focus, would you still give it the same value with its growing overseas business?”

Investors may already be having a change of mind in tolerating a steep valuation for Jollibee. After the stock sank 8% to a nine-month low on Wednesday following the purchase’s announcement, the shares fell as much as 4.8% Thursday. The sell-off sank the stock’s multiple to 28.99 times its 12-month estimated earnings, the lowest since March 2017 and a discount to its 34.75 three-year average. The benchmark stock index has a 16.42 multiple.

With $21 million in losses in 2018, analysts said Coffee Bean will be a drag for Jollibee, which booked a 15% drop in first-quarter earnings, its first decline in profit since fourth quarter 2015 due to losses at Smashburger, a US fast-food joint it took over in 2018.

“Investors liked Jollibee because of its concentrated business in the Philippines, so there is a risk it could lose part of that premium valuation with its overseas push,” COL Financial’s Mr. Dela Cruz said. “But if they are able to turn around both Smashburger and Coffee Bean then the market might give back that valuation.”

Luis Limlingan, head of sales at Regina Capital Development Corp., said Jollibee could need far longer than the usual three years it takes to revitalize its acquired businesses as it juggles both Smashburger and Coffee Bean. “Jollibee will take on one of its most ambitious acquisition maneuvers to date,” he said. — Bloomberg

PetroWind allocates P1.4 billion to expand capacity of Aklan wind farm

By Victor V. Saulon, Sub-Editor

PETROWIND Energy, Inc. is studying options to move forward the capacity expansion of its wind farm in Aklan at a cost of P1.4 billion, including the creation of a retail electricity supply (RES) business to sell the additional energy output.

“Hopefully if we are able to secure the off-take, we should aim to award the major contracts by the fourth quarter of this year,” Francisco G. Delfin, Jr., PetroWind executive vice-president, said after company officials showed the existing 36-megawatt (MW) wind project to reporters on Thursday.

He said the company plans to add 14 MW more, or seven more wind turbine towers to add to the existing 18 towers. Five of the turbines are in the town of Malay and the rest are in the nearby Nabas town.

“Total cost would be P1.4 billion. Mas mababa na (It will be lower),” he said, referring to the comparison with the P4.6-billion cost in building the existing Nabas-1 wind energy capacity in 2014.

PetroWind is a joint-venture firm owned by Thailand-listed BCPG Public Co. Ltd. (40%), EEI Power Corp. (20%) and PetroGreen Energy Corp. (40%). PetroGreen is a 90%-owned subsidiary of the Yuchengco-led publicly listed PetroEnergy Resources Corp.

Mr. Delfin said an “off-taker” or buyer of the planned Nabas-2 additional output could be forged through three ways, all of which are being studied by the company.

The first option is a traditional bilateral power supply agreement (PSA) with Aklan Electric Cooperative (Akelco) as the target off-taker. The coop’s power demand is about 61 MW, half of which is taken by popular tourist destination Boracay Island.

“Many of the hotels and establishments (in Boracay) are going back to Akelco rather than running their own generators,” Mr. Delfin said, adding that PetroWind’s proposition of providing energy will not only stabilize the distribution system but will also promote investments, jobs and boost tax payments through real property taxes and permits.

He said foreign tourists have become more conscious about sustainability, thus sourcing green power could be an added boost to the hotels and resorts. But the mode means going through a competitive selection process (CSP), thus the need to better package the company’s energy output.

The second option is participating in the government’s renewable portfolio standards (RPS), which requires utilities to source a portion of energy needs from renewables.

Mr. Delfin said the company had taken note of the National Renewable Energy Board’s announcement that it was considering to promote and install an additional 2,000 MW through the mechanism. The Department of Energy has also made the same pronouncement.

The third option is entering the retail electricity supply business, he said. The venture, should it push through, would be under PetroGreen.

“There are other existing RES companies that are approaching us in preparation for the availability of Nabas-2,” he said. “We’re really exploring the retail segment of the power industry.”

“We’re going to be applying soon for our RES license,” he said, noting that Supreme Court had put on hold rules relating to retail competition and open access (RCOA), including the issuance of new licenses.

Mr. Delfin said PetroWind was looking at internally generated funds, through PetroEnergy’s previous stock rights offering, to finance Nabas-2, and through bank financing.

Korean performer Cha Eun-woo to hold fan meet in Manila

CHA EUN-WOO

KOREAN actor and singer Cha Eun-woo will be coming to Manila for his first fan meet in October.

Wilbros Live will present “Cha Eun-woo 1st Fan Meeting Tour [Just One 10 Minute] in Manila” on Oct. 26 at the New Frontier Theater in Quezon City.

Cha Eun-woo started as a member of the popular K-Pop group Astro with the debut EP Spring Up. Astro subsequently named by Billboard as one of the best new K-Pop groups in 2016. He also ventured into hosting and acting while still part of Astro. The six-member boy group’s world tour this year, The 2nd Astroad Tour [Star Light], took them to different cities around the world including Taiwan, Hong Kong, Thailand, and the United States.

In 2018, Cha Eun-woo was cast in the romantic comedy series Gangnam Beauty, his first leading role on TV. It will air in the Philippines via ABS-CBN in August. He also currently stars in a historic drama, Rookie Historian Goo Hae-ryung, which airs on MBC and Netflix.

Tickets to “Cha Eun-woo 1st Fan Meeting Tour [Just One 10 Minute] in Manila” will go on sale beginning Aug. 10 via TicketNet.com.ph and at all TicketNet outlets nationwide. For more information, call the TicketNet hotline at 911-5555.

Bearing brunt of trade war, Singapore chipmakers cut jobs

SINGAPORE — Caught between a Sino-US trade war, political concerns over Chinese telecoms firm Huawei and slowing consumer demand, chipmakers in Singapore have started slowing production and laying off hundreds of jobs, firms told Reuters.

The slump in a sector that made up nearly a third of Singapore’s manufacturing output last year is reinforcing expectations that the export-driven economy could slide into recession in the coming months.

Making microchips for everything from cell phones to cars has long been central to the success of Singapore, the tiny trading island seen as a bellwether for the global economy.

“We are already seeing that this downturn is different,” said Ang Wee Seng, executive director for the Singapore Semiconductor Industry Association (SSIA).

Ang said he was “preparing for the worst” and putting his staff on standby to help any laid off workers try and find new jobs.

The semiconductor industry is a broad term for firms making electronic components including memory chips and microprocessors. Many of the world’s biggest chipmakers have operations in Singapore.

John Nelson, CEO of UTAC, a Singapore headquartered firm which tests and assembles chips, told Reuters he had started a “consolidation process” in Singapore which may result in a 10-20% head count reduction in the city-state by year end.

UTAC, backed by private equity firm TPG, has 10,280 employees worldwide of which around 1,700 are based in Singapore.

“We are taking the appropriate actions to make sure there is a future for our business in Singapore,” said Nelson, adding they may also add more days where the factory is closed and workers take unpaid leave.

Nelson said while the global industry was suffering, problems were magnified in Singapore due to high overhead costs like rent, wages and utilities.

“CROSSFIRE”
Lim Kok Kiang of Singapore’s Economic Development Board, a government agency which promotes the city-state as a business hub, said while the semiconductor industry faced challenges, Singapore remained competitive in the sector and has been attracting investment.

“The weaker global economic environment has affected demand in export-oriented sectors internationally, and the semiconductor sector is no exception,” he said.

Global semiconductor sales are expected to decline 12-13% in 2019, according to industry association SEMI, on course for their biggest drop since the dotcom bubble burst in 2001.

While the industry is used to swings in demand for the latest tech products, this slump is exacerbated by trade tensions between the United States and China.

The two superpowers have imposed tit-for-tat trade tariffs on a number of products, while the US has also banned firms from dealing with Huawei, the world’s biggest telecoms equipment maker, due to security concerns.

Firms in Singapore have been directly affected by these measures and caught in crossfire, said SSIA’s Ang, declining to give names.

Apple supplier AMS is another firm that has cut jobs in Singapore this year.

“We did reduce staffing in Singapore to adapt to more muted demand trends in the consumer market in the first half and to reflect improvements in manufacturing efficiency,” Patricia Moosburger, a company spokeswoman, said in response to emailed questions from Reuters.

Moosburger declined to comment on specifics but Singapore media reported as many as 600 people had been cut.

BELLWETHER ECONOMY
The semiconductor industry made up 28% of Singapore’s total manufacturing output in 2018, and 76% of its electronics production, official data shows.

Allen Ang of Aldon Technologies Services Group, a supplier of parts and services to semiconductor firms, said because Singapore exports most of its output, it is more vulnerable than other chipmaking hubs like Taiwan and South Korea which have more domestic electronics demand.

Ang estimates factories in Singapore are on average operating 10-15 percent below their utilization rate last year.

Singapore’s exports dropped to a six-year low in June, data released last week showed, mainly due to a 31.9% contraction in electronics exports — the sector’s biggest drop in a decade.

It was the latest in a slew of weak data that has reinforced some economists’ expectations the central bank will ease monetary policy in the coming quarters.

Singapore’s economy is seen as a gauge of global growth because international trade dwarfs its domestic economy.

The latest export data suggests Singapore is losing its electronics market share to other Asian countries, said ING economist Prakash Sakpal, citing its underperformance relative to Korea and Taiwan, as well as Malaysia, Philippines, Thailand.

But UTAC’s Nelson said despite the cutbacks, his firm was also making millions of dollars of investments in Singapore on equipment for new customers and projects, including for 5G networks, the next generation of mobile communications.

“I wouldn’t paint a picture that it’s all bad,” Nelson said.

“There is light at the end of the tunnel.” — Reuters

SSS digitizing processes, services

THE SOCIAL Security System said it is acquiring digital infrastructure. — BW FILE PHOTO

STATE-RUN Social Security System (SSS) said it is in the process of digitizing its processes to improve transactions after President Rodrigo R. Duterte in his State of the Nation Address included the pension fund in agencies that need improvement.

In a press release on Thursday, SSS President and Chief Executive Officer Aurora C. Ignacio said the pension fund has started acquiring new digital infrastructure “to fast track the full transition of SSS core and business processes to digitalization.”

“As mandated by our Social Security Commission ex-officio Chairperson Carlos G. Dominguez in his first order of business when he took office last March, he instructed to speed up the transition to the digitalization process. This is one of his priority policies under the new charter of the pension fund,” Ms. Ignacio said.

Mr. Duterte, in his SONA last Monday, said the SSS and the Land Transportation Office (LTO), Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR), Land Registration Authority (LRA) and the Home Development Mutual Fund or Pag-IBIG need to improve their services.

Finance Secretary Carlos G. Dominguez said in a briefing on Tuesday that the slow service of SSS is “costing the public money” and ordered the agency to develop a system using technology instead.

“I told them (SSS), you know the way you’re doing your business, our estimate is it cost you seven pesos to deliver P100. Now, that is too expensive. Other countries…if I remember right…Japan, 50 centavos to deliver a hundred pesos worth of benefits. We [in the Philippines] cost seven pesos. I said you cannot continue like that. That is not government money, that is the money of the people,” Mr. Dominguez said.

“So if it cost me seven bucks to deliver you a hundred…that means to say that seven bucks less I can give to somebody else… Your inefficiency is costing the public money, directly. So I said the first thing you do, you digitize, you do it, you develop a system that you can communicate with your clientele through modern technology, use the cellphone, you know, the smart app,” he added.

“Other countries can do it, why can’t we? You do it through computer and then we can…actually expand the benefits and make it easier for them to get the benefits,” Mr. Dominguez said.

At present, SSS’ online services include online applications for social security number issuance, payment reference number inquiry and generation, employment report submission, submission of contribution and loan collection lists, salary loan applications, certification of salary loan applications and filing for maternity and sickness notification.

Other electronic channels of SSS are My.SSS, SSS Mobile App, Self-Service Express Terminal, Interactive Voice Response System and Text-SSS.

The pension fund said in the same statement that out of 6,609 SSS-related concerns referred by 8888 and the government’s Contact Center ng Bayan, it resolved 99.55% or 6,554 cases. — B.M. Laforga

SC rules PSALM’s sale of power assets not subject to VAT

THE Supreme Court (SC) ruled the Power Sector Asset and Liabilities Management Corp. (PSALM) is not liable to pay P9.57 billion in value-added taxes (VAT) assessed by the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) on the sale of its power generating assets.

In a 16-page decision dated July 3, the court’s second division granted PSALM’s petition for review and reversed the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) decision.

The CTA Third Division found PSALM liable to pay P9.57 billion as deficiency VAT for the sale of the generating assets Masinloc, Ambuklao-Bingao and Pantabangan power plants in 2008.

The CTA ruled that the sale of generating assets of PSALM fall under “all kinds of goods and properties” that are subject to VAT under the Tax Code.

In reversing the tax appellate court’s decision, the SC cited a previous decision involving a similar issue which said the sale of generating assets is not subject to VAT as it is the mandate of PSALM under Electric Power Industry Reform Act (EPIRA) of 2001 to privatize the assets of National Power Corp.

“The sale of the power plants is not in pursuit of a commercial or economic activity but a governmental function mandated by law to privatize NPC generation assets,” the High Court ruled.

“The sale of the power plants is clearly not the same as the sale of electricity by generation companies, transmission, and distribution companies, which is subject to VAT under Section 108 of the NIRC. Thus, we do not find any merit in the arguments raised by the CIR (Commissioner of Internal Revenue),” it added.

Under the EPIRA, PSALM is directed to operate and maintain the assets of NPC and manage its liabilities.

The decision was penned by Associate Justice Antonio T. Carpio and concurred in by Associate Justices Estela M. Perlas-Bernabe, Alfredo Benjamin S. Caguioa, Jose C. Reyes, Jr. and Amy C. Lazaro-Javier. — Vann Marlo M. Villegas

Pets welcome at Robinsons malls

PETS will be welcome in Robinsons Malls as the Robinsons Malls Happy Pets Club is now accepting members. The Happy Pets Club Nationwide Grand Launch will be held on Oct. 6. To join the club, submit the following requirements at the nearest Robinsons Mall: a duly accomplished Happy Pets Club form, an updated vaccination record of the pet, two copies of a 1×1 photo of the pet. Meanwhile, if one registers pets at the following malls — Robinsons Magnolia, Robinsons Novaliches, Robinsons Place Antipolo, and Robinsons Place Las Piñas — and present a single/accumulated receipt worth P3,000, they take home a Happy Pets Club Welcome Kit. In celebration of the World Animal Day on Oct. 6, the malls are arranging for a fun-filled day for the club members with special events and activities such as pet blessing, free vet consultation, free anti-rabies vaccinations, and talks on how to be a responsible pet owner. There will also be booths, pocket activities, and freebies like pet clothes, bandanas, and pet food from partner merchants. To know more about the Happy Pets Club, follow RobinsonsMalls on Facebook; or follow @RobinsonsMallsOfficial on Instagram; and @RobinsonsMalls on Twitter.

Jobstreet to study overseas workers demand

JOB search site Jobstreet.com (Jobstreet) has signed an agreement with the Labor department to survey the international market for Filipino workers.

Jobstreet Philippines Country Manager Philip A. Gioca told BusinessWorld said that the collaboration with the labor department will help the Philippines adjust to developments in global demand.

“The problem with the Philippines is that when there is a low demand… people will produce so much. We need to have good calibration to (be in tune with) the world’s supply of talent,” he said.

He added that the Department of Labor and Employment (DoLE) and Jobstreet have collaborated before in research but in the upcoming study, “We will try to project demand and the supply of talent… over periods like the next five years.”

Mr. Gioca said that the study will be released six months from now and will monitor various industries.

The study aims to also answer how to manage occupations where demand and supply have been fluctuating, which he said include nursing. He added that schools have limited their output nurses because of past reports of oversupply.

“There’s high demand and limited supply (for nurses)… Around three to five years ago, we had an oversupply of nurses so the colleges decreased the number of classes. Now, (those decisions) have taken their toll,” Mr. Gioca said. — Gillian M. Cortez

UnionBank launches stablecoin PHX for use on its blockchain platform

UNIONBANK of the Philippines, Inc. launched its own stablecoin to provide rural banks under its blockchain-powered platform easier access to remittance and payments.

In a statement on Thursday, the Aboitiz-led bank said it is issuing PHX, a stablecoin to be used on its i2i network of rural lenders and UnionBank.

UnionBank President and Chief Executive Officer Edwin R. Bautista said PHX is a “tokenized” fiat directly pegged to the Philippine peso and is backed by the blockchain technology.

“(Stablecoins) utilize the technology behind cryptocurrency. Behavior of these mirrors that of fiat because it is always worth the value of the underlying fiat currency, hence, no volatility,” Mr. Bautista said in an e-mailed response.

Successful live transactions were conducted on Wednesday, executed by three rural banks participating in the i2i network, namely Summit Rural Bank, Progressive Bank and Cantilan Bank.

“Each of three rural banks performed buy, transfer and redemption transactions for PHX. The three banks were also able to conduct domestic remittances to one another using PHX,” UnionBank said.

“(PHX) enables transparent and automatic execution of payments,” said Ramon Vicente V. De Vera II, UnionBank senior vice president and head of its fintech business group. “Reconciliation challenges of the past are no longer an issue. Meanwhile, audit and compliance are made easier.”

i2i is a blockchain-based platform that connects rural banks to each other and to UnionBank, providing small lenders access to services which can be coursed through the system. Launched in 2018, i2i is now handled by UBX, UnionBank’s financial technology arm.

Blockchain is a distributed data ledger which involves a large network of entities where data is stored in “blocks.” The storage units are continuously updated and being secured using cryptography, making data management and data-driven processes decentralized, tamper-proof and more transparent.

PHX will be made available to rural banks under the i2i platform. These lenders can buy or sell stablecoins though their UnionBank accounts.

Given its interoperability, PHX can soon be used across various platforms and electronic wallets.

“This has the potential to make transactions, payments and other use cases more accessible, efficient and inclusive,” the bank said.

“In the future, the advantages and value of a token economy will become very apparent in terms of exponential progress in efficiency, productivity, governance and customer service,” UnionBank chairman Justo A. Ortiz said.

On Tuesday, UnionBank piloted its cross-border remittance service for local rural banks through blockchain.

The ninth largest bank in the country in asset terms posted a P2.16-billion net income in the first quarter, down 26% from P2.93 billion recorded in the same period in 2018.

UnionBank shares closed unchanged at P60 apiece on Thursday. — K.A.N. Vidal

Your Weekend Guide (July 26, 2019)

Tertulia de Memoria

PALACIO de Memoria hosts its first heritage weekend lecture series, dubbed “Tertulia de Memoria,” on July 27 and 28. The restored pre-war Roxas Boulevard estate and gardens serve as the backdrop and venue for this two-day event that aims to foster a renewed sense of heritage appreciation. With broadcast journalist Ces Drilon as moderator, the speakers include heritage and cultural advocate Isidra Reyes; architect, author and professor Dr. Gerardo Lico; ABS-CBN Film Restoration head Leo Katigbak; Cultural Heritage Studies Program Head of the Ateneo de Manila University, Dr. Fernando N. Zialcita; playwright and essayist Floy Quintos; and Heritage Conservation Society trustee Conrado Alampay. The forums range from adaptive reuse for buildings, to art and film restoration. There will be special sunset movie screenings of digitally re-mastered and restored Filipino movies: on July 27, 5 p.m., Peque Gallagas’ Oro, Plata, Mata (1982); July 28, 5p.m., National Artist Eddie Romero’s Ganito Kami Noon, Paano Kayo Ngayon (1976). Tickets are available at Palacio de Memoria on 95 Roxas Blvd., Parañaque, at www.ticketworld.com.ph, and at selected TicketWorld outlets. For details visit https://www.facebook.com/thepalaciodememoria/.

Sheena Easton concert

RANDOM Minds presents Grammy-award winning singer-songwriter Sheena Easton in a concert, Sheena Easton Live in Manila, on July 26, 8 p.m., at the Theatre at Solaire. For tickets and schedules, visit TicketWorld (www.ticketworld.com.ph, 891-9999).

Ang Huling El Bimbo

FULL HOUSE Theater Company presents the final run of Ang Huling El Bimbo, a musical featuring the songs of the Eraserheads, with performances until Aug. 15 at the Newport Performing Arts Theater, Resorts World Manila, Pasay City. For tickets and schedules, visit TicketWorld (www.ticketworld.com.ph, 891-9999).

Rak of Aegis

THE hit Pinoy jukebox musical Rak of Aegis returns to the PETA Theater Center, with ongoing performances until Sept. 29. The show features the songs of Aegis. Tickets are available through TicketWorld (www.ticketworld.com.ph, 891-9999).

DTI taps more credit delivery partners for P3 program

THE government is boosting its Pondo sa Pagbabago at Pag-asenso (P3) program with an expanded network of credit delivery partners to help micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) access loans more easily.

The Department of Trade and Industry (DTI), through government-owned and -controlled corporation Small Business Corp., introduced yesterday 10 new credit delivery partners from rural areas for its P3 program.

These partners — which may be rural banks, cooperatives or market vendor associations — help the P3 program by processing loan applications from MSMEs. They will act as underwriter for loan applications and monitor registered P3 accounts.

Trade Secretary Ramon M. Lopez said in a program in Pasay City that having a wide network of credit delivery partners is seen to increase the number of MSMEs to benefit from the government lending initiative.

“For this to thrive and for this to have high repayment rates, we have to partner with (financing institutions), cooperatives… because you would have a better understanding of the situation on the grassroots because you’re already there,” he said.

The 10 new credit delivery partners come from Isabela, Nueva Ecija, Pampanga, Bulacan, Marikina City, Cebu City, Davao City, Surigao del Sur and Quezon Province.

With the new partners, SB Corp. now has a total of 353 credit delivery partners helping lend to almost 90,000 MSMEs across the country. The total loans disbursed to micro- entrepreneurs under the P3 program stood at P2.9 billion as of July 23.

Started in 2017, the P3 program aims to discourage the use of loan sharks, which are known for the “5-6” scheme by offering MSMEs with loans from P5,000 to P200,000 with a 2.5% monthly interest.

“The P3 is supposed to replace about P30 billion — worth of ‘5-6’ (lending),” Mr. Lopez said, noting the government has to “reach out to more (MSMEs).”

One of the long-term plans of the DTI for the program is to have a law signed that will institutionalize P3 with a P4-billion budget allocation.

“We will ask for the President to certify it (P3 bill) urgent, because in the first place, this was started by that brainstorming with (him). The main purpose is really to institutionalize the program. Ibig sabihin kahit wala na kami [Which means even when we’re gone], there will be a P3 program para sa mga micro (for MSMEs),” he said. — Denise A. Valdez

Ryanair Portuguese cabin crew to strike

DUBLIN — Ryanair cabin crew in Portugal are set to strike for five days in August in a dispute over pay and conditions, the SNPVAC union said on Wednesday.

The industrial action comes as Ryanair pilots in Ireland and the United Kingdom are holding ballots on a possible strike action in August. SNPVAC said it had not yet decided which days in August it would strike.

Ryanair, Europe’s largest low-cost carrier, suffered a series of damaging strikes last year.

Management say significant progress has been made since, with collective labor agreements concluded with a number of pilot unions throughout Europe.

But SNPVAC said Ryanair has refused to comply with a protocol signed last November, which it said included holiday pay, 22 days of annual leave per year and full compliance with Portuguese parental law.

“Facing the intransigence from Ryanair and the lack of interest of the Portuguese government on guaranteeing the fundamental labor rights to their citizens that work for Ryanair, the cabin crew had no other choice but to return to the industrial conflict,” SNPVAC said in a statement.

Ryanair did not immediately respond to a request for comment. — Reuters

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT