Home Blog Page 7334

DoH logs fewer than usual virus cases due to technical issues

PHILIPPINE STAR/ MICHAEL VARCAS

THE DEPARTMENT of Health (DoJ) reported fewer than the usual coronavirus infections and deaths on Wednesday, again citing technical issues.

It posted 3,656 new coronavirus infections, bringing the total to 2.74 million. The death toll rose to 40,977 after five more patients died, while recoveries increased by 228 to 2.63 million, it said in a bulletin.

There were 67,061 active cases, 77.9% of which were mild, 6.8% did not show symptoms, 4.6% were severe, 8.69% were moderate and 2% were critical.

The agency said 20 duplicates had been removed from the tally, 16 of which were reclassified as recoveries, while five recoveries were reclassified as deaths.

Two other cases were relisted as recoveries, DoH said.

“The low number of reported recoveries and deaths today are due to technical issues,” the agency said in a statement. Additional recoveries and deaths would be reflected reports in the coming days, it added.

DoH said 53% of Metro Manila’s intensive care units had been occupied, while the national rate was 59%.

The presidential palace on Tuesday said the government would expand a new coronavirus alert level system first tested in the capital region into other parts of the country starting Oct. 20.

An inter-agency task force put Batangas, Quezon Province including Lucena City under Alert Level 2. Also under the same alert level are Bohol, Cebu City, Lapu-Lapu City, Mandaue City and Cebu Province in central Philippines and Davao De Oro, Davao Del Sur and Davao Oriental in Mindanao.

Cavite, Laguna, Rizal, Siquijor, Davao City and Davao del Norte would be under Alert Level 3, under which theaters would be allowed to operate. The capacity of allowed businesses would also be increased.

Negros Oriental and Davao Occidental will be under Alert Level 4, which bans theaters, amusement parks and playgrounds, karaoke bars, live voice or wind-pipe performances and contact sports establishments.

The country’s pandemic task force placed Metro Manila under Alert Level 3 from Oct. 16 to 30. — Kyle Aristophere T. Atienza

Duterte hits Senate for threat to cut Executive budget

PCOO.GOV.PH

PHILIPPINE President Rodrigo R. Duterte on Tuesday night slammed senators for threatening to cut the 2022 budgets of agencies.

“You threaten the budget of different agencies of the Executive because the officials refuse to attend your hearings,” he said in a taped Cabinet meeting. “They threaten to paralyze the government.”

Last month, the House of Representatives passed on third and final reading its version of the P5.024-trillion national budget for next year.

The Senate has yet to approve the budget bill, which they are examining after state audit reports showing deficiencies in the use of public funds by some agencies.

Mr. Duterte dared senators to slash the budgets of executive departments. “Reduce the budget of the Office of the President to zero, go ahead,” he said, while threatening to block the release of funds to agencies once the national budget is approved.

“Will your funds reach you without going through me? What if I don’t release them? Tit for tat,” he said.

The tough-talking leader has barred Cabinet officials from attending the Senate blue ribbon committee’s hearing probing questionable state pandemic deals.

Mr. Duterte has denied corruption in pandemic-related contracts, including those bagged by Pharmally Pharmaceutical Corp.

The President earlier said the country’s pandemic response was being hampered by the Senate investigation. — Kyle Aristophere T. Atienza

Price freeze sought on basic goods as oil prices continue to increase   

PHILIPPINE STAR/ MICHAEL VARCAS

LAWMAKERS from the progressive Makabayan bloc have called for a price freeze on basic goods as oil prices continue to increase for the eighth consecutive week due to increasing global oil prices.  

The party-list representatives, led by Gabriela Rep. Arlene D. Brosas, filed House Resolution 2310 on Tuesday urging the national government to address the impact of soaring oil prices to commodities.  

“The nonstop oil price hikes are setting off an adverse domino effect on the price of basic goods and services at a time when majority of Filipino families are suffering from the economic fallout of a prolonged pandemic,” they said in the resolution.  

Local oil firms on Monday raised gasoline prices by P1.8 per liter (/L), and increased diesel and kerosene prices by P1.5/L and P1.3/L, respectively.  

The lawmakers said the price freeze on basic goods can be justified through President Rodrigo R. Duterte’s Proclamation No. 1218 signed last month extending the period of state of calamity until Sept. 12, 2022 due to the coronavirus pandemic.  

Republic Act 7851 or the Price Act provides for the automatic imposition of a price freeze on basic necessities for 60 days when there is a declaration of a state of calamity.    

“President Rodrigo Duterte has not taken any decisive action to curb the rising oil prices and the consequent price hikes of basic commodities, and has instead shamelessly engaged in politicking and attacks against political opponents,” the Makabayan solons said.  

The Department of Energy has earlier asked Congress to amend the oil deregulation law in order for the government to intervene in sudden prolonged hikes in retail prices and require the unbundling of retail product costs.   

Energy Secretary Alfonso G. Cusi said in a letter that the consecutive increases in oil prices is attributed to a sudden surge in global demand as countries resume more economic activities, slowed production, stockpiling ahead of winter season, and international sanctions on oil-rich nations such as Iran and Venezuela. — Russell Louis C. Ku 

Senator pushes gov’t to source at least P5B to continue transport service contracting program 

PHILIPPINE STAR/ MICHAEL VARCAS

A SENATOR on Wednesday pushed the government to pull together at least P5 billion to continue the transport service contracting program for the benefit of both public utility vehicle (PUV) drivers and commuters amid rising fuel costs.  

Senator Ana Theresia “Risa” N. Hontiveros-Baraquel noted that there is still P3 billion in unreleased funds allocated for the transport sector under the pandemic response law.  

“It is also necessary to find additional funds that can match the allocation for service contracting found in Bayanihan II that was only wasted,” she said in Filipino. “Drivers need to be paid on time and enough for this system to be of benefit.”  

Meanwhile, the Transportation department denied on Wednesday the allegation that its attached agency, the Philippine National Railways (PNR), had procured “overpriced” pandemic-related items from Pharmally Pharmaceutical Corp.  

Ms. Hontiveros told the Senate blue ribbon committee hearing Tuesday that PNR paid rates that were above its price catalogue. 

The Transport department, in a statement, said the emergency procurement of critical items for the use of its personnel had no irregularities. “PNR is most ready to present or submit the necessary documentary proofs of its small value procurement, such as relevant market studies or canvasses at that time, as needed.” — Alyssa Nicole O. Tan 

DoH requests release of additional P2.7B for healthcare workers 

PHILIPPINE STAR/MICHAEL VARCAS

THE HEALTH department has requested the release of another P2.7 billion for the payment of special risk allowances due to 119,353 healthcare workers. 

Health Assistant Secretary Maylene M. Beltran said they have already asked the Budget department for the fund, which will cover additional personnel as requested by various healthcare facilities.  

“The list comes from our operating units. Some or most of them are directly or indirectly catering to the COVID patients,” Ms. Beltran told the Senate budget hearing on Wednesday. 

During the hearing, Senators inquired if the additional workers included staff in non-COVID wards, to which Ms. Beltran said that some “utility workers, non-medical and allied medical personnel” were included, but not all have been added to the list.  

Latest government data show 456,013 healthcare workers, or 87% of the total eligible, have received their special risk allowance. — Alyssa Nicole O. Tan 

UK gov’t, UNICEF to help Bangsamoro gov’t address COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy, refusal 

BASILAN PROVINCIAL GOVT.

THE UNITED Kingdom (UK) government and the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) will be assisting the Bangsamoro region in a program to address hesitancy and refusal to get coronavirus vaccines.  

In a statement on Wednesday, the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (BARMM) government said the partnership with the UK and UNICEF will involve the Ministry of Health, Bangsamoro Information Office, and the information offices in the island provinces of Basilan, Sulu and Tawi-Tawi.  

The program will focus on expanding the dissemination of correct information on vaccines, training local health teams on behavior change communication, and mobilizing stronger support from local governments.   

“The fight against COVID-19 (coronavirus disease 2019) is far from over, especially with the emergence of new variants. Through the renewed partnership with UNICEF and the UK government, we are confident that we will be able to address misinformation concerns,” BARMM Chief Minister Ahod B. Ebrahim said.   

The UK and UNICEF previously assisted the BARMM in its coronavirus emergency response under a program that ran from Aug. 2020 to March 2021.  

“This time, we will be working closely with the Ministry of Health to focus on COVID vaccination. We all know that refusal and hesitancy are really major issues,” UNICEF Chief Field Officer for Mindanao Andrew Morris said.   

Ministry of Health Director-General Amirel Usman said the region’s full vaccination rate is currently only 10% of the more than 2.4 million eligible population  

“For our fully vaccinated individuals, we only have 10%. So our efforts are way (behind) and it’s not even half of the 70% (target for herd immunity). We have enough supply of vaccine right now but we face several challenges,” Mr. Usman said.  

Apart from hesitancy and refusal to receive the jab, the region is also faced with brand preference for the vaccine, rural health units that do not have doctors, late reports due to internet connectivity problems, lack of manpower for data management, and misinformation.  

“In this several months partnership project, we will have an extra focus on the islands because it is very diverse with multiple languages. So there is a need for extra communication efforts there,” Mr. Morris said. — MSJ 

Napocor brings power to 1,200 households in Eastern Samar 

NAPOCOR.GOV.PH

THE NATIONAL Power Corp. (Napocor) said it has brought energy supply to remote communities across Eastern Samar, so far covering 1,200 households.  

“Recently, we have opened facilities in Cagusu-an, Habag, Inapulangan in Guiuan, and Hilabaan and Tikling in Dolores,” Napocor Vice President for Small Power Utilities Group (SPUG) Larry I. Sabellina said in an emailed statement on Wednesday. 

In March this year, the government entity switched on its diesel power plants in Casuguran. 

Mr. Sabellina added that Suluan, Sta. Monica and Tarnate are “scheduled for energization” by yearend. 

Napocor said the agricultural sector stands to benefit from the presence of SPUG’s facilities in off-grid areas. 

Under the Electric Power Industry Reform Act of 2001, Napocor is required to bring power to areas not connected to the grid. The entity operates SPUG plants in 189 municipalities across the country. — Angelica Y. Yang 

TPB to launch tour routes for motorbike enthusiasts 

TPB/ANGEL ERAN

THE TOURISM Promotions Board (TPB) is launching a campaign to encourage motorcycle enthusiasts to go on road trips and take routes that feature the country’s tourist attractions.     

“We are pushing our boundaries to come up with even more safe and creative ways to set the tourism industry and all those who depend on its path to recovery, TPB Chief Operating Officer Maria Anthonette Velasco-Allones said in a statement Tuesday.   

The Philippine Motorcycle Tourism Program will be officially launched on Nov. 19 with a hybrid webinar promoting the Philippines as “a fun and safe destination” and highlighting road safety during travel.  

A motorbike ride, with around 250 participants, will then be held on Nov. 20-21, starting at Rizal Park in Manila. The journey will cover the five provinces of Calabarzon — Cavite, Laguna, Batangas, Rizal, and Quezon.  

The motorcycle tourism program, Ms. Allones said, “showcases interesting culture and heritage sites, shops, restaurants, and other tourism products all over the country that Filipinos can discover themselves on two wheels.”  

In line with the program, the tourism agency is also supporting three riders’ events:  

• Motorbike Tour in Tarlac and Nueva Ecija on Oct. 21-22 organized by Department of Tourism’s Central Luzon office  

• Halal Foods Rediscovery Motorcycle Ride, which will highlight the promotion of halal food and establishments  

• 10th Mindanao Freedom Ride on Nov. 5-12 spearheaded by Norminring Motorbikes. 

171 more Filipinos repatriated from Macau  

ANOTHER 171 overseas Filipinos in Macau were repatriated on Tuesday, bringing the total from the country to 4,757 since the start of the coronavirus pandemic in March last year.  

“The repatriation program will continue as long as regular commercial flights to the Philippines have yet to resume,” Philippine Consul General to Macau Porfirio M. Mayo, Jr. said in Filipino in a statement.  

He also assured that the consulate continues to work towards the inclusion of Macau in the “green list” of jurisdictions under the government’s classifications for countries.  

Under the latest guidelines, fully-vaccinated passengers arriving from countries in the green list are no longer required to undergo facility-based quarantine, subject to presentation of a negative RT-PCR test taken within 72 hours prior to departure from the port of origin. — Alyssa Nicole O. Tan 

Does sustainability please the crowd?

MACROVECTOR-FREEPIK

(Part 2)

Last week we introduced the concept of crowdfunding and how it is now being used to get sustainability off the ground. We discussed how crowdfunding involves two parties: the beneficiaries of the campaign and its funders or backers. We explained how millennials are more and more interested in being altruistic and funding sustainability projects and we also explained why someone would ask funding from the crowd in the first place. This is really a no-brainer given that projects need money and it is a common occurrence that campaigners will not have enough resources to execute the projects they want on their own. But we also highlighted how not everything is about money; crowdfunding allows democratization of finance but also democratization of ideas. The crowd provides creative input as well as a network for the campaigner in ways he would never have had access to.

Today we discuss the funders’ motivations for crowdfunding. That is, why would random individuals back projects of people they do not even know and whose risks are very high? And the million-dollar question: what attracts funders to select to fund one project over hundreds of thousands of projects currently available to them?

FUNDERS’ MOTIVATIONS FOR CROWDFUNDING SUSTAINABILITY
We know from Business Ethics research that investors are motivated by both financial and non-financial returns and recent studies of crowdfunding backs this idea. Funders of crowdfunding campaigns choose the type of campaign based on characteristics that matter to them. Some crowdfunders (equity-based or lending-based) are typical investors expecting a financial return in the form of future profits. Rewards-based crowdfunders are motivated by a bargain or the attractiveness of a non-released product. Whereas donations-based crowdfunding essentially attracts philanthropists that want to demonstrate their social awareness or simply contribute to social change.

Research has suggested that having a sustainability orientation may increase a small venture’s legitimacy and have a positive impact on a crowdfunding campaign. This may be related to the fact that recent research developments in sustainability point towards a consensus of a positive relationship between corporate social performance and corporate financial performance. Further it has been found that responsible investing can reduce a portfolio’s risk and some evidence suggests that adopting a sustainability orientation may stimulate creativity. One study argues that a sustainability orientation forces managers to confront the tensions that exist between complex economic, social, and environmental considerations, and that confronting these tensions leads to more creativity. Sustainability may thus appeal to people who are looking for the material benefits of new and innovative products and services. It appears that ceteris paribus, crowdfunders that have an intrinsic financial or material motivation may also be motivated to choose sustainability projects strategically.

The behavioral finance literatures point out that investors are motivated to invest based on non-financial factors such as ethics. Studies argue that individuals may willingly choose immaterial utility such as happiness or satisfaction gained from ethical considerations within their utility maximization. The growth in socially responsible investments is empirical proof of this.

Indeed, some statistics have shown that crowdfunders tend to be young, male, primarily from North America and Europe, and with considerable earning power. This age demographic has indicated preferences for working for employers that are socially or environmentally friendly and they prefer to buy from suppliers of green or socially responsible products. A recent study has provided some evidence in this direction. By studying two categories (technology and film) on the US Kickstarter platform, researchers found that projects with a sustainability orientation (social or environmental) increases funding success and pledged amounts compared to commercial-only projects. It thus appears that regardless of motivation, whether financial or non-financial, sustainability projects may have more appeal to investors than traditional projects.

QUALITY AS A MODERATING FACTOR IN CROWDFUNDING SUCCESS
Funders must simplify their choices. However, the due diligence conducted by crowdfunders is necessarily minimal because available information is limited, many ventures have little history, many entrepreneurs have little experience, and data are typically self-reported. Signals are thus extremely important in campaigns. High quality projects and more prepared entrepreneurs are more likely to succeed such as by using videos, updating constantly, and even spelling errors matter much more in such projects. Just like in other situations of financing, information asymmetry is the largest determinant of risk in a crowdfunding campaign. Signals of project quality thus moderate whether a project will be successfully funded or not.

URGENCY AS A MEDIATOR IN SUSTAINABILITY CROWDFUNDING SUCCESS Finally, decision-makers’ attention and resources are limited, but given the discussion on the need for pragmatic solutions to pressing global concerns, sustainability projects may be considered some of the most urgent today. A sense of urgency can motivate contributions and a spike in activity has been seen in platforms at the beginning and end of each campaign. Indeed, framing a project as urgent may appeal to the crowd and may entice them to financially support a venture.

(To be continued.)

Note: This paper is based on a Masters in Finance thesis at IESEG written by Jade Tissier and supervised by the author. References are available upon request.

 

Daniela “Danie” Luz Laurel is a business journalist and anchor-producer of BusinessWorld Live on One News, formerly Bloomberg TV Philippines. Prior to this, she was a permanent professor of Finance at IÉSEG School of Management in Paris and maintains teaching affiliations at IÉSEG and the Ateneo School of Government. She has also worked as an investment banker in The Netherlands. Ms. Laurel holds a Ph.D. in Management Engineering with concentrations in Finance and Accounting from the Politecnico di Milano in Italy and an MBA from the Universidad Carlos III de Madrid.

What are we prepared to leave behind?

MACROVECTOR-FREEPIK

A lot of people, I am sure, are just waiting to exhale. Perhaps thinking that this pandemic is temporary, unique, and a one-off, they still believe that the world will eventually go back to the way it was in 2019. And maybe they are right. But from where I sit, I reckon many changes are actually here to stay. That’s why I am already pondering what am I prepared to leave behind.

Change, for the better or for worse, is inevitable. Everything changes over time. Very few things stay as they are for years and beyond. And, despite what one may think, I believe change is never a matter of choice. It is always prompted or influenced by some action, incident, or event. Change is never the start but the result; it is not action but reaction.

I note three recent developments that, to my thinking, are strong indicators of the big changes that are happening. The first is a recent report commissioned by Google Philippines that estimated “Digital Transformation” to create up to P5 trillion in annual economic value for the Philippines, driven mainly by technologies that would help businesses mitigate the impact of COVID-19.

The second is a report on Iceland and how their government offices benefitted from a shorter workweek; how productivity rose enough to ensure that all services were still provided as needed; and, as a consequence of the study, why 86% of Icelanders would eventually have the right to a shorter workweek of four days.

The third development involves new advances particularly in battery technology, and the views of Japanese scientist Akira Yoshino, a co-winner of the 2019 Nobel Prize in chemistry for his work on lithium-ion batteries, on the potential convergence in the near future of the automotive and information technology industries in future mobility.

BusinessWorld reported recently that in a study for Google Philippines, economists at Singapore-based AlphaBeta looked into the development, application, and potential in the country of key technologies like artificial intelligence, Internet of Things (IoT), mobile internet; cloud computing; big data; financial technology; advanced robotics; and additive manufacturing.

And they found that “digital technologies can unlock up to P5 trillion worth of economic value annually in the Philippines by 2030… by generating productivity gains, revenue boosts, cost savings, and GDP increments.” BusinessWorld also quoted the AlphaBeta report as noting that “sectors projected to be the largest beneficiaries [of digital technologies] are the consumer, retail and hospitality; education and training; and agriculture and food sectors. By allowing the creation of new business models and productivity savings, these technologies could create significant economic value for the Philippines.”

In addition, Google Philippines Country Director Bernadette Nacario was quoted as saying that “the COVID-19 pandemic is likely to have long-term implications in three aspects of the Philippine economy, namely: the emergence of a hybrid workplace that supports digital freelancing, accelerating the shift towards digital payments, and severe disruptions to the business operations of small enterprises.”

In the last two years we have already witnessed the start of this Digital Transformation and how key technologies have been leveraged to change how we work, consume, and communicate. Work and education have become remote for a lot of people, and mobility and commuting has become less of a concern with respect to work, learning, and retail consumption.

For those who have adapted well to the changes in working and learning environments, and in the manner of purchasing and paying for goods and services, the changes are likely to become permanent. Having already invested in new tools and technologies to adapt to a digital lifestyle, they are most likely to leave behind old models that include over-the-counter banking, paper-based bills and statements, and physical shopping.

As I had noted in a previous column, I believe the world has changed so much in 2020 and 2021 that going back has become practically impossible for me. I am no longer the same consumer I was in 2019, and the changes that occurred in my way of doing things are here to stay. Even my demands in terms of physical infrastructure have changed, from enclosed, airconditioned spaces to wide, open spaces that are well-ventilated and have natural lighting; energy efficient and environment-friendly; and, can be accessed with minimal commuting.

I have also noted that it was the congruence of situation, environment, and technology that brought us to where we are now. And it is these same factors that continue to fuel the transition particularly to remote work. And while COVID-19 may have accelerated the transition, I truly believe that changes in the workplace were bound to happen eventually, as a result of technological changes.

Online publication Big Think reported recently that a new study in Iceland documented “the recent success of one of the largest experiments to date on a reduced workweek.” Carried out by the Icelandic government and published by Autonomy, a UK think tank, the report suggests that a substantial portion of the economy could switch over to a short workweek with little in the way of negative effects, Big Think said.

Big Think reported that two experiments were done. The first, from 2014 to 2019, was by Reykjavík’s city government, and involved more than 2,500 workers at playschools, city maintenance facilities, care-homes for people with various disabilities and special-needs, and beyond. The second, by the Icelandic national government from 2017 to 2021, involved 17 workplaces across the country.

“Workers in the experimental locations saw their hours reduced from 40 to 36 or 35 hours per week with no loss in pay. The exact way these hours were organized was determined by the individual workplace involved. Many opted to split the hours among four days, while others worked a five-day week with one workday being shorter,” Big Think reported.

“Both studies produced similar results. The reduction in hours caused either no change or an increase in productivity and improvements in the reported work-life balance of employees. While many employees were concerned that more work would be crammed into less time, the data show that the workers were actually working less,” it added.

It also noted that “improvements in efficiency were found in every workplace. Employees worked faster. Time-wasting events, like unnecessary meetings, were curtailed. Routines were changed to be more efficient, and shifts and schedules were restructured. Overtime was needed in some offices, but only sparingly. Importantly, services were provided at the same levels as they were before the reduction in work hours. The well-being of workers dramatically improved, with many reporting increased time with their families, lower stress levels, and a better ability to balance their work and home lives.”

As a result of the two trials, Big Think noted that 86% of Icelandic workers were now on contracts that either reduce their workweek or grant them the right to reduce their workweek in the future.

And last but not least among these new developments is the recent Reuters interview of Japanese scientist Akira Yoshino, a co-winner of the 2019 Nobel Prize in chemistry for his work on lithium-ion batteries, who “sees more disruption ahead as transportation and digital technology become one industry, sharing lithium battery technology.”

Reuters quoted Yoshino: “Right now, the auto industry is thinking about how to invest in the future of mobility. At the same time, the IT industry is also thinking about the future of mobility. Somewhere, sometime, with the auto industry and the IT industry, there is going to be some kind of convergence for the future of mobility.”

“The one to look out for is Apple. What will they do?” he asked. “I think they may announce something soon. And what kind of car would they announce? What kind of battery? They probably want to get in around 2025.”

Yoshino, according to the Reuters interview, also believed that the “biggest potential” in the Electric Vehicle (EV) industry is in “ride-sharing” or in pay-per-use, rather than people buying their own electric cars. “If autonomous electric vehicles can become practical, that will cause a huge change in the way people use vehicles,” he noted.

These key developments around the world, on how digital transformation is changing the way we work and do things, are going to bring about more changes sooner than later. In this line, I believe that those who can quickly adapt to these changes can enjoy some degree of competitive advantage. However, adapting requires the fortitude to embrace change, and the willingness and readiness to pay the price of leaving the old world behind.

 

Marvin Tort is a former managing editor of BusinessWorld, and a former chairman of the Philippine Press Council

matort@yahoo.com

Citizens groups’ concerns about transparent elections

MACROVECTOR-FREEPIK

Citizens groups which have vowed to help the Commission on Elections (Comelec) achieve transparent and honest elections on May 2022 have had regular consultations with civil society organizations and IT practitioners about possible gaps in the automated election system. These gaps are being closely studied by these citizens groups and IT practitioners (who had long called everyone’s attention to these gaps in vain for the last 10 years) when even non-administration political parties, presumably still preoccupied with forming their respective powerhouse slates, have not publicly raised questions about the lack of consolidated rules to address these gaps.

IT practitioners say they have fought lonely battles without any support from the legal profession, congress, media, and even political parties and other interest groups. Comelec- and Church-accredited groups like the Parish Pastoral Council for Responsible Voting (PPCRV) have devoted themselves mainly to voters’ education and guidance, which a great number of groups, including Comelec, are doing; poll watching (on election day) and quick count based on unaudited figures spewed out by vote counting machines and transmitted to several servers, the number and purpose of which have yet to be clearly explained.

Other groups, like the Tagapagtanggol ng Watawat (TNW), the Network for Justice and Compassion (NET JC), Faith Initiative, and the Automated Election System (AES) Watch have enumerated about a dozen and a half or 18 areas of concern in a number of public forums over the past several months. Some of them, like the AES Watch and the UP-based Center for People Empowerment and Governance, have, however, been at it for years.

The first issue raised is any person’s right to take pictures of the Election Returns (ERs) and Certificates of Canvas (COC). The main reason for raising this issue is the right of the public to see the ER in real time before it is transmitted by any means to the municipal or city canvassers. It is envisioned that right after the precinct closes and a count is conducted, the public will be able to take pictures of the ER and upload the same to a public website.

This system duplicates the process of transmitting the ERs to the municipal/city board of canvassers. Transparency is achieved by Comelec uploading the count in a public website. That public website will be the fourth recipient of data aside from the Kapisanan ng Brodkaster ng Pilipinas (KBP), the PPCRV, among others. Citizens groups caution against the use of a transparency server given many questions about the operation of such a server.

The Voter Verifiable Paper Audit Trail (VVPAT) was a feature added to the election system in 2016. The voter is issued a receipt right after he casts his vote. The receipt serves as a check against fraud and machine breakdown: the voter can check through the receipt given to him if the persons he voted for were registered in the receipt. The receipt is placed inside a receptacle. The VVPAT, however, is no guarantee that the Vote Counting Machine (VCM) counted one’s vote for a particular candidate or candidates. The following question therefore arises: do the readings match among the VCM, the VVPAT and data registered in the Secure Data (SD) card and the transmitted data? The VVPAT shows what the VCM read but it cannot show that what the VCM read was registered in the Secure Data (SD) card and were the same data transmitted for canvassing.

One answer to this question is provided by the Ransom Manual Audit (RMA). By doing the RMA on the same day right after the polls close (but not after several days in a different location), we move closer to ensuring that the vote is registered properly. The RMA therefore helps guarantee accuracy in a transparent manner.

The National Movement for Free Elections (Namfrel) has consistently been pushing for the same-day RMA since the implementation of the automated election system in 2010. The RMA serves as a check between the actual count of individual ballots and the figures declared in the ERs, COCs, the digitally generated ERs in possession of the PPCRV, and, eventually, the data in the SD card.

Citizens groups insist that the RMA be done right then and there at the close of the polling precinct among randomly selected precincts. The Comelec emphasizes that there are too many logistical problems in doing the RMA right after the close of polling precincts. The poll body also states that the random selection of the precincts in randomly selected areas be in accordance with the scientific processes of the Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA). Using other methods like the tambiolo employed by the Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office for its lotto draws does not conform with PSA specifications. Citizens groups point out that Comelec’s insistence that the RMA be done at the Comelec office in Intramuros is fraught with risks as it requires that VCMs/SD cards be brought to the National Capital Region, especially if they come from far flung areas in different parts of the archipelago. Citizens groups ask: why create that gap of several days when so many things can happen at any stage of the transport process?

The thorniest issue however, is the absence of Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR) of the AES law. It is a matter of standard legislative and legal practice that IRRs are promulgated by the agency implementing the law soon after the passage of the said law. In Comelec’s case however, there is still no IRR 24 years after the law was passed in 1997 and amended in 2007.

In a Senate hearing on Monday on the Comelec budget efficiently conducted by re-electionist Senator Risa Hontiveros, vice-chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, the citizens groups, as expected, brought up the IRR issue again. The Comelec responded that it had issued “many IRRs” and General Instructions (GIs), which is however only for Comelec and Department of Education personnel and others tasked to help manage and administer the elections, and not a comprehensive document covering all stakeholders.

Hontiveros pointed out that piecemeal (“pira piraso”) GI’s do not make an IRR. The citizens groups chimed in to say that GIs do not respond to the intent of some important election processes such as the digital signatures, public and Comelec website, and continuity plan, to name a few. Citizens groups assert that the Comelec just has contingency plans in cases of defective VCMs and CCS or Consolidation and Canvassing System. They point out that the GIs do not have an end-to-end coverage of the AES Law as they have no GIs for the central and transparency server which, by the way, is not required under the AES law.

These concerns and many more will continue to be raised until after some satisfactory solution is formulated. The basic problem is that confidence in the integrity of elections is at an all-time low and various questions have been raised about the Comelec itself. It does not help that by February 2022, all seven commissioners would have been appointed by the President under an environment of partisanship triggered by the super high stakes in the 2022 elections.

Clearly the burden of having an honest and transparent election falls on the shoulders of the President, who would have appointed all seven commissioners in the Comelec. It must be remembered that the Comelec will have the government and all its instrumentalities like the Armed Forces of the Philippines, the Philippine National Police, and the local government units, among others, under its control for 120 days before and 30 days after the elections.

With such power and the offer of help from citizens groups and civil society, Comelec commissioners and those who appointed them are in a truly make or break situation.

 

Philip Ella Juico’s areas of interest include the protection and promotion of democracy, free markets, sustainable development, social responsibility and sports as a tool for social development. He obtained his doctorate in business at De La Salle University. Dr. Juico served as Secretary of Agrarian Reform during the Corazon C. Aquino administration.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT