Home Blog Page 8723

Gin Kings savor uniqueness of latest PBA title conquest

By Michael Angelo S. Murillo, Senior Reporter

WITH the manner with which it was achieved, the Barangay Ginebra San Miguel Kings cannot help but take special pride in their latest Philippine Basketball Association (PBA) title conquest and savor the uniqueness of it all.

On Wednesday, the Kings completed their assault on the Philippine Cup title after beating the TNT Tropang Giga, 82-78, in Game Five of their best-of-seven finals to take the series, four games to one.

It was a culmination of what was an interesting journey by Barangay Ginebra done in an extraordinary setup — a “bubble” — amid the ongoing coronavirus pandemic.

“The experience here is so different, a little surreal,” said Kings coach Tim Cone following their Game Five victory in a virtual press conference.

The latest title of Barangay Ginebra is its 13th in league history but first Philippine Cup jewel in 13 years. It was the 23rd PBA crown for Mr. Cone and his fifth with the Kings.

The PBA restarted its pandemic-hit Season 45 in October in the hopes of squeezing at least one conference and help in jump-starting the return of sports in the country.

It was not an easy ride for the PBA and the participants as they had to grapple with uncertainty at the start, including having suspected coronavirus cases, and continuously being on guard moving forward.

But through it all, the Kings forged ahead with their thrust. Never mind if along the way they, too, had questions if they could pull it off and come out on top.

“I remember coming into the bubble saying to myself, ‘Can we even make the playoffs?’ I mean, at that time, we did not have Greg [Slaughter] and we didn’t have LA [Tenorio] and Japeth [Aguilar],” said Mr. Cone, referring to Mr. Slaughter who took a sabbatical from basketball after last season and Messrs. Tenorio and Aguilar who were the last to join the team in the bubble in Pampanga because they were nursing varying ailments.

“But credit to our players. They just kept on working, working and working, and found a way to win it. I’m proud of them. [Also] There was so much out-of-the-box thinking that had to go into being successful here. I think you really had to think out of the box,” Mr. Cone said.

Adding, “When we get back to Manila and we look back on this one, I think we’ll just be amazed at how it all evolved and us ending up winning the championship.”

In clinching the title, the Kings had to deal with another gallant stand from a shorthanded TNT crew, which played sans key cogs Jayson Castro and Ray Parks Jr. because of injuries.

Barangay Ginebra trailed the Tropang Giga, 73-68, with less than six minutes left to play before the former sprinted to the finish and claimed the victory.

Mr. Aguilar had a career-high-tying 32 points to lead the Kings. He also had online rebounds and three steals.

Stanley Pringle finished with 13 points and six dimes while LA Tenorio had 10 points and six assists.

Mr. Tenorio, meanwhile, was adjudged finals most valuable player after averaging 13.6 points, 6.2 assists, 2.8 rebounds and 1.4 steals in winning his first All-Filipino title.

“It’s just so unique. Hopefully, there’s only gonna be one bubble championship. And if there’s only one bubble championship, we got it. And that’s so cool,” Mr. Cone said.

Gilas Pilipinas number 31 in FIBA’s world rankings

In Asia and Oceania, the national team ranks sixth

THE Philippines retained its spot at number 31 in the world after International Basketball Federation (FIBA) updated its rankings following the second window of its Continental Cup Qualifiers.

The country’s standing remained steady after a youth-laden Gilas Pilipinas team made a good account of itself in the FIBA Asia Cup Qualifiers in November, sweeping Thailand in their two-game series by an average winning margin of 28 points.

The twin victories kept the Philippines unscathed in the Asia Cup Qualifiers while taking the driver’s seat in Group A with a 3-0 record.

In Asia and Oceania, the country is ranked sixth, behind Australia (3), Iran (23), New Zealand (25), China (28) and Korea (30).

The United States is still the number one-ranked team in the world, followed by Spain and Australia. Argentina and Serbia complete the top five.

Russia is the only newcomer to the top 10 after climbing two spots to No. 9 and switching places with the Czech Republic, which dropped to No. 11 after suffering defeats to lower-ranked teams in Denmark and Belgium in the FIBA EuroBasket 2022 Qualifiers.

Also in the top 10 are France (6), Greece (7), Lithuania (8) and Brazil (10).

South Sudan, coached by former National Basketball Association star and federation president Luol Deng, experienced the biggest rise in the latest update, climbing nine points to No. 98.

It won two of three games in the FIBA AfroBasket 2021 Qualifiers in Kigali, Rwanda.

The biggest drop in the world ranking, meanwhile, was suffered by Madagascar, which dropped 30 places to No. 124 after losing in the FIBA AfroBasket 2021 Qualifiers to Tunisia by 37 points, to Central African Republic by 26, and to Democratic Republic of Congo by 18.

Due to the suspension of FIBA competitions, an adjustment was made to the algorithm for the rankings by extending the expiration date of past results by eight months in order to ensure that results from two Olympic Games are at all times included in the calculations, which weigh data from the past eight years.

FIBA member nations/teams have the opportunity to improve on their rankings in the last of three FIBA Continental Cup Qualifiers windows set for February next year. — Michael Angelo S. Murillo

Brooklyn Nets’ Kevin Durant: Wasting no time on (James) Harden thoughts

BEYOND the physical acclimation of returning to the court on a daily basis, Kevin Durant plans to invest his time getting to know his role with the Brooklyn Nets.

That role doesn’t include general manager responsibilities.

Durant said Wednesday he’s not wasting a second thinking about trade rumors tying the Nets to James Harden, his former teammate with the Oklahoma City Thunder, because there is too much on his plate without also piling on personnel duties.

“I don’t think about James Harden at all. I mean, he doesn’t play on our team,” Durant said.

The 31-year-old Durant also provided new insight into his expected role with the Nets this season. Durant’s next game will be his first since the 2019 NBA Finals, when he ruptured his Achilles as a member of the Golden State Warriors. A few weeks later, following surgery, he signed a four-year deal with the Nets.

The Nets made the playoffs last season with Durant and Kyrie Irving out and then hired Steve Nash as head coach.

The Nets plan to play a smaller lineup and Durant outlined Nash’s thoughts of having him split time between point guard and center this season. At either spot, the 6-foot-10 scoring machine will be a difficult check.

“I’ve never been one to predict anything, but I like our chances of going out there and competing at that high level every single night,” Durant said. “And as tough as that is in this league, I think we’re capable of doing it and we got a lot of guys who have experienced so much in this league. We got champions on this team. …” — Reuters

Donaire fight off after he tested positive for coronavirus

THE scheduled ring return of Nonito “The Filipino Flash” Donaire this month is not pushing through after he tested positive for the coronavirus.

Set to face Puerto Rican Emmanuel Rodriguez on Dec. 19 for the vacant World Boxing Council bantamweight title, United States-based Donaire (40-6) saw his push derailed by the positive testing.

The result came after Mr. Donaire, 38, underwent coronavirus testing as part of the health and safety protocols in the lead-up to the bout taking place at the Mohegan Sun in Uncasville, Connecticut.

Reports have it that organizers are now weighing their options in light of the unfortunate turn

of events.

One option is having a replacement fighter for Mr. Donaire, possibly another Filipino in Reymart Gaballo.

Still another direction to take, according to reports, is for the World Boxing Council (WBC) to postpone the clash altogether and wait for a little while before having Messrs. Donaire and Rodriguez fight.

Interestingly, Mr. Donaire was originally set to challenge WBC bantamweight champion Nordine Oubaali of France for the title on Dec. 12 until the latter tested positive for the coronavirus last month.

The WBC then ordered the title vacated and have Mr. Oubaali declared as “champion in recess” while allowing Messrs. Donaire and Rodriguez to contend for it, with the winner then facing  the Frenchman once he is cleared to return.  

Four-division champion Donaire and Mr. Rodriguez (19-1), the former International Boxing Federation bantamweight champion, are coming off losses in their previous fights, both at the hands of undefeated Japanese boxing superstar Naoya Inoue.

Mr. Donaire made the Japanese sweat and struggle before absorbing a unanimous decision loss in November last year.

Mr. Rodriguez, for his part, faced Mr. Inoue in May 2019 and was knocked out in the second round to lose his IBF title.

Both Messrs. Donaire and Rodriguez were angling to use their scheduled fight as leverage to gain traction anew in their division. — Michael Angelo S. Murillo

Inter Milan suffer third successive group stage elimination

MILAN — Inter Milan were knocked out of the Champions League in the group stage for the third season in a row on Wednesday after being held to a 0-0 draw at home by Shakhtar Donetsk, who were also eliminated.

Lautaro Martinez rattled the crossbar in the seventh minute of the Group B match, but Inter created few chances after that, despite dominating possession at a soggy San Siro.

Shakhtar finished level with Borussia Mönchengladbach on eight points, but lost out to the Bundesliga side — beaten 2-0 by Real Madrid — on their head-to-head record to finish third and will go into the Europa League instead.

Inter, who could have gone through with a win, finished bottom of the group with six points after drawing three of their six games. Real won the group with 10 points. — Reuters

Antetokounmpo ‘not focused’ on contract with Milwaukee Bucks

ANXIETY in Milwaukee over Giannis Antetokounmpo staying with the Bucks beyond this season continues to rise.

The National Basketball Association (NBA) MVP said Wednesday he has locked in on the 2020 season, not his much-discussed future.

“Right now, I am not focused on that,” Antetokounmpo said Wednesday. “I am just trying to focus on myself.”

Antetokounmpo, who turned 26 on Sunday, faces an NBA-imposed deadline of Dec. 21 to decide whether he’ll sign a “supermax” contract with the Bucks and remain with the team or roll the dice and consider entering free agency after the 2020-21 season. The Bucks can offer a five-year, $228.2 million deal that would increase to $243.7 million if the league salary cap returns to pre-COVID levels.

His current, expiring deal was worth $100 million for four years.

Antetokounmpo said Wednesday he’s leaving any contract talks to his agent, Alex Saratsis.

Before reporting to the Bucks last week, Antetokounmpo told a TV station in Greece that he is open to teaming up with another superstar — as LeBron James did with Anthony Davis last season — if it means winning.

“This is a statement that I have never made before: If LeBron and Kevin Durant and Anthony Davis came to Milwaukee; I would have been good with that,” Antetokounmpo said. “I am not interested if I am the top, second or third name, okay? Because I want to win.

“For sure, when I was 18 or 19 years old, maybe I didn’t understand what you need to do to win. But right now, I am 25 and I want to win because when I retire, that’s what people will remember. And if I got LeBron, KD, Davis, if all those came, I wouldn’t mind at all. I don’t care if I am the top (player) on the team.”

Multiple teams have been rumored to be waiting in the wings for the two-time NBA MVP if he opts not to stay in Milwaukee, including the Golden State Warriors, Miami Heat and Dallas Mavericks.

By then, it will be clear to Bucks teammates, including All-Star Khris Middleton, whether the “Greek Freak” is long for Wisconsin.

“I have confidence in what we’ve done in the past and what we can do forward,” Middleton said, reminiscing on his own free agency decision. “So as long as I’m confident in that and show him that I’m confident in what we can do and what we can accomplish and keep grinding together, I’m not going to worry about it too much.” — Reuters

Mass testing

Mass testing will clearly be the fulcrum of the National Basketball Association’s safety protocols moving forward. With training camp having already begun and other ancillary activities ramping up heading into the start of the 2020-21 season in two weeks, officials and players are being trusted to follow the league’s 134-page “guide” on navigating the new competitive environment. There will be no bubble protection, however — which is to say rules designed to maintain the schedule, already under pressure off a quick turnaround and compressed to address new realities, figure to be followed in the beach.

Indeed, the NBA isn’t going for zero positive results. Unlike the setup it controlled throughout the play-ins and playoffs at the Walt Disney World Resort in Florida, the league knows there are simply too many extraneous variables for it to bat 1.000. Rather, it’s hoping for manageable setbacks. It’s trying to prepare for every conceivable scenario in recognition of the complexities of running a tournament in multiple cities covered by differing, even contradictory, regulations. And, outside of logistics, it needs to deal with a bigger headache: People are people, and likely to backslide by accident or by design.

Take, for instance, the manner in which All-Star James Harden saw fit to comport himself over the last week. In his desire to force the Rockets to trade him, he decided to be a no-show at the start of training camp. Fine; it can be argued that he’s just looking out for Number One, his status as a Forty-Million-Dollar Man notwithstanding. Adding injury to insult, however, was the fact that he instead opted to attend a party in Atlanta and then while the time away in Las Vegas in violation of quarantine orders. For good measure, he also deemed himself above the supposedly unbreakable directives of keeping distance and wearing a mask.

Per the front office, Harden now has to take, and pass, no less than six tests for the virus before being cleared for practice. All things considered, his flippant attitude is not merely a Rockets problem. It’s an NBA problem — one that, in the worst-case scenario, can be compounded by 449 other players on the payroll of its franchises. Which is why the league will be navigating a logistical and public relations nightmare, and why, for all the preparations it has painstakingly made, nothing is etched in stone. It’s only as strong as its weakest link. No wonder all and sundry are crossing their fingers.

 

Anthony L. Cuaycong has been writing Courtside since BusinessWorld introduced a Sports section in 1994. He is a consultant on strategic planning, operations and Human Resources management, corporate communications, and business development.

WorldRemit projects that 2020 OFW remittances will be level with last year’s

Contrary to previous projections of a 20%–40% drop in remittances, WorldRemit sees the year ending at almost the same level as last year’s total, with remittances from overseas Filipino workers (OFWs) either declining or increasing by 1%–2%.

“Filipinos, regardless of where they are, will continue to send money back home,” said Earl Melivo, WorldRemit’s Philippine country director. 

December is generally a peak time for remittances to the Philippines from OFWs, and WorldRemit said this trend will continue despite the COVID-19 pandemic.

“The resilience of holiday remittances to the Philippines this year can be attributed to the easing of lockdown restrictions in many countries allowing return to work for most OFWs. As well as availability of financial aid from governments in other nations,” said Mr. Melivo in a statement.  “Christmas is looking optimistic, and we are foreseeing a peak at this time.” 

According to a WorldRemit survey of 3,167 adults in the UK, the US, Canada, and Australia, 84% of those who have previously sent money to the Philippines are planning to send more money or about the usual amount for Christmas this year. Fifty-three percent will do so to help family and friends back home who have been financially impacted by the pandemic. More than a third (37%), meanwhile, want to make up for not being home in person this year.

The Middle East was the most affected send region to the Philippines this year, with the biggest declines in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) because of restrictions and repatriations, followed by the seafaring industry. Both registered double-digit declines in the second quarter.

These declines were offset, however, by increasing volumes from the US, Canada, Singapore, HK, and Taiwan, said Mr. Melivo.

“We’ve already experienced the worst,” said Mr. Melivo in a roundtable discussion. “Many of the host countries are already adapting to the new norm. Given the positive prospect of us having vaccines, we only see growth by 2021.”

International remittance to the Philippines reached $33.5 billion in 2019. These remittances come from around 223 countries, with the top 10—the United States, KSA, UAE, Singapore, UK, Japan, Taiwan, Canada, Hong Kong (HK), and Qatar—making up 78% of the volume. Land-based OFWs contributed 78% of total cash remittances to the Philippines last year, while seafaring Filipinos made up the rest of the pie.

WorldRemit serves more than 50 countries. It plans to partner with financial companies to educate OFWs and their families beyond remittances. Less than 5% of fund transfers on their platform are purposely sent for investments and savings. — Patricia B. Mirasol

China tells cabin crew to wear diapers on risky COVID flights

China’s aviation regulator is recommending cabin crew on charter flights to high-risk COVID-19 destinations wear disposable diapers and avoid using the bathroom to reduce the risk of infection.

The advice comes in a 38-page list of guidelines for airlines to prevent the spread of coronavirus. The sixth edition echoes similar instructions in previous, less lengthy versions.

The Civil Aviation Administration of China (CAAC) said the recommendation applies for charter flights to and from countries and regions where infections exceed 500 in every one million people.

The diaper advice is in a section on personal protective equipment, which also recommends the following for cabin crew:

• Medical protective masks

• Double-layer disposable medical rubber gloves

• Goggles

• Disposable caps

• Disposable protective clothing

• Disposable shoe covers

• Flight crew should wear masks and goggles, but they don’t need diapers.

Other advice for the flights includes dividing the cabin into “clean area, buffer zone, passenger sitting area and quarantine area,” separated by disposable curtains. The last three rows should be designated as an emergency quarantine area, said CAAC. CAAC declined to disclose any more details on the guidelines.

China’s aviation market was hit hard at the onset of the outbreak in Wuhan and subsequent spread around the country. But it has recovered—on the domestic front at least—to close to pre-pandemic levels, while other regions such as Europe and the US struggle to bring COVID-19 under control.

Airlines have insisted that it is safe to fly during the pandemic, partly thanks to the hospital-grade air filters on planes, but some researchers say it isn’t yet clear to conclude there’s minimal risk. Some cases have documented transmission on flights when passengers wore masks and sat far apart. — Will Davies/Bloomberg

Pounded by pandemic ‘storm,’ poor nations need climate finance more than ever

poverty slum area
Yannick Glemarec, head of the Green Climate Fund, said it was essential to align funding for COVID-19 recoveries, climate action, and international development so that the money could achieve the largest possible impact in terms of curbing global warming and tackling poverty. Image via PhilStar

BARCELONA — Many developing nations are under huge financial stress from the COVID-19 crisis, making it more important than ever that they receive the funding promised by rich nations to help them tackle climate change, said the head of the Green Climate Fund (GCF).

Yannick Glemarec said the poorer countries the fund supports lack the financial means to jumpstart their economies and are struggling to access capital, while their revenues from taxes, commodity exports, and remittances have plunged.

“For a number of developing countries, it’s a perfect storm,” the executive director of the multi-billion-dollar GCF told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.

As a result, it would be “dramatic” if wealthy governments backed away from providing the $100 billion a year they promised to raise from 2020 onwards to enable vulnerable nations to grow cleanly and adapt to a warming planet, he said in an interview.

That pledge is a key pillar of the 2015 Paris Agreement on climate change, and countries speaking at a summit to mark the pact’s fifth anniversary on Dec. 12 should reaffirm it and show how it will be met, he added.

“This commitment is critical to enable the most vulnerable to be able to achieve their climate ambition,” said Mr. Glemarec, a former senior United Nations development official.

The latest figures from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) show that climate finance channeled to developing states rose by 11% to $79 billion in 2018—about $20 billion short of the 2020 flagship goal.

Donor countries should also maintain broader aid to poorer nations, despite their public finances also coming under pressure because of the pandemic, Mr. Glemarec added.

Last month, the British government said it would cut its aid spending to 0.5% of gross national income in 2021, down from a legally binding target of 0.7%, although it vowed to honor a promise to double its climate finance in the coming five years.

Mr. Glemarec also urged wealthy governments to make a far bigger effort to ensure their coronavirus stimulus spending led to greener economies—which has not been the case so far, he said.

“We are still at an early stage of the recovery, so we still have time for a course correction. But the first few steps are not in the right direction,” he said, noting some countries were doing better than others.

According to the Energy Policy Tracker, compiled by a coalition of research groups, 29 major economies have so far pledged about $256 billion to fossil fuels in their pandemic recovery packages, or 53% of all public money for energy-intensive sectors, with only 35% earmarked for clean energy.

Mr. Glemarec said it was essential to align funding for COVID-19 recoveries, climate action, and international development so that the money could achieve the largest possible impact in terms of curbing global warming and tackling poverty.

A paper published in the journal Nature Climate Change in August said an economic recovery tilted towards green stimulus and reducing fossil fuel investments would make it possible to shave 0.3 degrees Celsius off future warming by 2050, he noted.

Given the accelerating pace of planetary heating, developing countries needed money now to deal with climate impacts, he added.

“Not only are we coming to a danger threshold far faster than we thought, but the danger threshold is far lower than we thought two to three decades ago—and so we have to step up effort both for (emissions) mitigation and adaptation,” he said.

LESS RISKY
To that end, the GCF has set a new goal of approving $1 billion at each board meeting it holds— usually three per year—to drive projects in things like clean energy, forest protection, and making infrastructure and agriculture more resilient to climate change.

Since the pandemic hit, it has also provided grants to help developing nations plan green recoveries from the crisis.

A key GCF aim now, Mr. Glemarec said, was to use its resources to mobilize more money from the private sector for “blended finance” projects working with those most vulnerable to climate change, who are often perceived as too risky to invest in.

At its November board meeting, for example, the GCF approved $150 million for a climate fund to attract private investment into cities, states, or provinces across 42 countries in Africa, Asia, Eastern Europe, Latin America, and the Caribbean.

The money will back projects such as renewable energy, energy-efficient construction, and solid waste management at municipal and other levels underneath central governments, working with small and medium-sized companies, Mr. Glemarec said.

While 70% of climate solutions need to take place at the “subnational” level, they suffer from chronic under-funding.

By contributing a 20% stake that will assume any losses first, the GCF hopes to smooth the way for other investors to put $600 million into the fund, managed by asset management firm Pegasus Capital Advisors.

The GCF has also allocated $30 million for a debt facility—which plans to raise $100 million overall—that will provide loans for off-grid energy companies to help them ride out the pandemic downturn, organized by Acumen, an impact investment nonprofit.

“Making blended finance work for the poor was important for us before COVID-19—now it’s critical,” Mr. Glemarec said. — Megan Rowling/Thomson Reuters Foundation

What do the UK allergic reaction cases mean for Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine

Image via Reuters

Britain’s medicines regulator has advised people with a history of significant allergies not to get the Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine after two people reported adverse reactions on the first day of its rollout in the UK.

Here are some questions and answers about the cases and what they might mean.

WHAT EXACTLY HAPPENED?
UK officials said there have been two reports of anaphylaxis and one report of a possible allergic reaction since rollout began. Anaphylaxis can cause throat swelling, breathing trouble, and difficulty swallowing, according to the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma & Immunology. Anaphylaxis is an overreaction of the body’s immune system, which the UK National Health Service describes as severe and sometimes life-threatening.

WHO SHOULD NOT GET THE VACCINE, ACCORDING TO UK REGULATORS?
British regulators initially responded by saying anyone with a history of a significant allergic reaction to a vaccine, medicine or food should not take the shot. An adviser to the group later said it was “tweaking” advice in part to say a food allergy was not a risk.

Late on Wednesday, the UK regulator said anyone with a history of anaphylaxis to a vaccine, medicine or food should not get the vaccine.

Pfizer had excluded people with a history of significant adverse reaction to vaccines or its vaccine’s ingredients from late-stage trials.

HOW DOES THIS AFFECT PROSPECTS FOR U.S. AUTHORIZATION?
US regulators are expected to consider emergency authorization of the Pfizer vaccine soon after a Thursday meeting of advisers.

Moncef Slaoui, who is spearheading the US government’s vaccine development efforts, said on Wednesday he expected the British allergic reactions would be considered in the US authorization process and that people with known severe allergic reactions probably should not take the vaccine until more was understood.

WHAT DO DOCTORS SAY?
Some praised UK regulators’ caution, while others said broad restrictions were not warranted by available evidence.

“For the general population, this does not mean that they would need to be anxious about receiving the vaccination,” said Stephen Evans, a professor of pharmacoepidemiology at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine.

What would be wise, he said, would be “for anyone who has known severe allergic reaction such that they need to carry an EpiPen to delay having a vaccination until the reason for the allergic reaction has been clarified.”

Mayo Clinic virologist Gregory Poland, who has advised US regulators, described Britain’s early reaction as “overdoing it,” pointing to the initial response about food allergies, which he said “have nothing to do with this.”

“I would have said, ‘If you’ve had anaphylactic-level reactions to vaccines, we want to know about that so we take extra care,’” he said. “That doesn’t mean I wouldn’t immunize you. But I would do it in a more controlled setting.”

Peter Openshaw, a professor of experimental medicine at Imperial College London, praised the way the reactions had been handled. “The fact that we know so soon about these two allergic reactions and that the regulator has acted on this to issue precautionary advice shows that the monitoring system is working well,” he said.

Mitchell Grayson, director of the division of allergy and immunology at Nationwide Children’s Hospital in Ohio, voiced concern over how the issue might reduce interest in vaccinations. “I’m worried the whole event will cause millions of people to choose not to get vaccinated because of what they heard,” he said.

HOW COMMON ARE SEVERE OR SIGNIFICANT ALLERGIES?
“In the UK in 2012 there were around seven hospital admissions per 100,000 people for severe allergies. This included different triggers such as foods, drugs and insect stings,” said Louisa James, an expert in immunology at Queen Mary University of London. Fatalities remain very rare and have not increased even as hospital admissions have risen in many countries. — Reuters

Facebook faces US lawsuits that could force sale of Instagram, WhatsApp

The complaints on Wednesday accuse Facebook of buying up rivals, focusing specifically on its previous acquisitions of photo-sharing app Instagram for $1 billion in 2012 and messaging app WhatsApp for $19 billion in 2014.

WASHINGTON/PALO ALTO — Facebook Inc. could be forced to sell its prized assets WhatsApp and Instagram after the US Federal Trade Commission and nearly every US state filed lawsuits against the social media company, saying it used a “buy or bury” strategy to snap up rivals and keep smaller competitors at bay.

With the filing of the twin lawsuits on Wednesday, Facebook becomes the second big tech company to face a major legal challenge this year after the US Justice Department sued Alphabet Inc.’s Google in October, accusing the $1 trillion company of using its market power to fend off rivals.

The lawsuits highlight the growing bipartisan consensus to hold Big Tech accountable for its business practices and mark a rare moment of agreement between the Trump administration and Democrats, some of whom have advocated breaking up both Google and Facebook.

The complaints on Wednesday accuse Facebook of buying up rivals, focusing specifically on its previous acquisitions of photo-sharing app Instagram for $1 billion in 2012 and messaging app WhatsApp for $19 billion in 2014.

Federal and state regulators said the acquisitions should be unwound—a move that is likely to set off a long legal challenge as the deals were cleared years earlier by the FTC.

“For nearly a decade, Facebook has used its dominance and monopoly power to crush smaller rivals, snuff out competition, all at the expense of everyday users,” said New York Attorney General Letitia James on behalf of the coalition of 46 states, Washington, DC, and Guam. Alabama, Georgia, South Carolina, and South Dakota did not participate in the lawsuit.

Ms. James said the company acquired rivals before they could threaten the company’s dominance.

Facebook’s general counsel Jennifer Newstead called the lawsuits “revisionist history” and said antitrust laws do not exist to punish “successful companies.” She said WhatsApp and Instagram have succeeded after Facebook invested billions of dollars in growing the apps.

“The government now wants a do-over, sending a chilling warning to American business that no sale is ever final,” Ms. Newstead said.

Ms. Newstead also raised doubts about alleged harms caused by Facebook, arguing that consumers benefited from its decision to make WhatsApp free, and rivals like YouTube, Twitter, and WeChat did “just fine” without access to its developer platform.

In a post on Facebook’s internal discussion platform, Chief Executive Mark Zuckerberg told employees he did not anticipate “any impact on individual teams or roles” as a result of the lawsuits, which he said were “one step in a process which could take years to play out in its entirety.”

Comments were turned off for Mr. Zuckerberg’s post, as well as for other posts on the lawsuits shared by Newstead and Chief Privacy Officer for Product Michel Protti, according to copies viewed by Reuters. Newstead also warned employees not to post about the cases.

Facebook did not immediately respond to questions about the posts.

PROTRACTED FIGHT
Mr. Zuckerberg told employees in July that Facebook would “go to the mat” to fight a legal challenge to break up the company, calling it an “existential” threat, according to audio of internal company meetings published by The Verge.

Although breakup remedies are rare, some antitrust experts said the case was unusually strong given damning statements by Mr. Zuckerberg plucked from Facebook’s own documents, like a 2008 email in which he said “it is better to buy than compete.”

Other experts such as Seth Bloom of Bloom Strategic Counsel said the FTC complaint was “significantly weaker” than the DOJ’s lawsuit against Google.

“We’re talking about acquisitions that are six or eight years old and it will be difficult for a court to order divestitures of many years ago,” Mr. Bloom said.

Investors echoed similar concerns.

“I do not know if the FTC or DOJ will be successful in breaking Facebook up. I’m assuming this will be dragged out in the courts as FB defends itself,” said Daniel Morgan, a portfolio manager at Synovus Trust in Atlanta, Georgia.

The lawsuits are the biggest antitrust cases in a generation, comparable to the lawsuit against Microsoft Corp. in 1998. The federal government eventually settled that case, but the yearslong court fight and extended scrutiny prevented the company from thwarting competitors and is credited with clearing the way for the explosive growth of the Internet.

Last month, Facebook said it was buying customer service start-up Kustomer, in an acquisition that the Wall Street Journal said valued Kustomer at $1 billion.

Facebook also bought Giphy, a popular website for making and sharing animated images, or GIFs, in May. That acquisition has already drawn scrutiny from the United Kingdom’s competition watchdog.

Facebook shares fell as much as 3% after the news before paring losses to close down 1.9%. — Diane Bartz, Nandita Bose, and Katie Paul/Reuters