Reinventing internal audit in the age of disruption
CHANGE IS COMING faster than ever. As technology and the world economy changes at an accelerated pace, so too does the level of emerging risks that come with it due to regulatory requirements and globalization, among others. These changes are having a significant impact on how Internal audit (IA) functions in an organization.
Management relies on IA to provide assurance on the effectiveness of internal controls and company processes, while also providing support to a diverse array of risk management and business process improvements. Because of how recent developments in technology are affecting the way business is operationalized, stakeholders also expect IA to cope with the volatility. It is further expected to elevate its profile to have the ability to identify, anticipate, assess and address emerging risks coming out of business changes; transform the IA function to provide improved strategic value to stakeholders; and provide cost efficiencies to the business.
Current trends in technology and emerging risks are significantly challenging how IA strategy and approach are designed and executed.
DATA ANALYTICS AS A GAME CHANGER
Traditionally, when audit is performed, auditors focus on what could go wrong. They identify and test controls that address what could go wrong by extracting and selecting a representative sample out of the population. Given that the process of sample selection is random, the sample might not be properly representative and the resulting audit may miss critical areas and fail to identify all relevant issues.
Using analytics, IA can examine an entire population by mining past data to better understand what has already happened, anticipate future events, and help determine the effectiveness of future decisions and actions. It allows analysis of the full population versus sample data in order to identify anomalies, see patterns and note any trends that may point to significant control or process deficiencies.
IA’s adoption of analytics does not only mean acquisition of tools and techniques but also requires a change of mindset. IA needs to know what it is looking for to identify the appropriate data to pull, and the analytics program to develop. This is only the first step. The ability to institutionalize the process to make it repeatable and scalable across the organization is a journey that will require the right resources, project management and governance.
RISE OF ROBOTICS TO DRIVE EFFICIENCIES
In past columns, we have written about how robotic process automation (RPA) is working to streamline operations, enhance productivity and reduce mistakes in organizations, as well as how companies can leverage RPA to upskill existing talent to create combined human and robotic work forces. The same holds true for IA, where RPA can handle the execution of repetitive and controllable processes thereby freeing up human talent for more critical, value-added, judgment-based work. Robotics can also be integrated with analytics, thereby leveraging large volumes of data to perform cognitive tasks.
An example is a global engineering company that uses robotics during the IA process to perform analytics on bank transactions in identifying any mismatched amounts, dates, currencies or bank account numbers. Similarly, another use of RPA can be to format and upload data into an analytics tool, allowing the system to ensure 100% coverage of data, with faster processing time and reduced chance of human error.
AMPLIFIED RISK RELATED TO SOCIAL MEDIA
Social media are redefining the way we develop our networks and even manage businesses. A majority of online adults use social networking sites to do business or share opinions, views, photos and media. This disruption presents new challenges and opportunities to companies, which result in the rise of significant risks, such as employees inadvertently leaking sensitive company information, criminal hackers and multiple platforms creating more access to viruses, malware and phishing. IA’s business insight and control expertise play an important role in providing awareness on how social media can be better managed across the organization and identifying and evaluating threats brought by social media to the organization’s information security protocols.
BUILDING TRUST IN A CLOUD ENVIRONMENT
Cloud computing has become a force in the marketplace and has become common as companies seek cost reductions and streamline operations. When systems are moved to the cloud and managed by third parties, due diligence related to controls are often missed out. Use of cloud computing presents certain risks that need to be considered when IA designs its audit procedures. Examples include infrastructure and architectural risks (ability of providers to achieve agreed performance), regulatory and compliance risks (transparency in security controls), contractual risks and business continuity risks among others. IA’s role is vital in evaluating whether proper governance is in place, adequate information security policies and practices exist, and clear metrics are documented to assess a service provider’s performance.
INCREASING IMPORTANCE OF CYBERSECURITY
The increased reliance on information emerging from technology-driven channels also increases technology-based risks. Greater ease of access to information is now the new normal, and companies need to find the balance between enabling technology and protecting assets from malicious individuals. As discussed in previous articles in this column, cybersecurity risks are a challenge for every company. Companies, regardless of size, are often targeted for their intellectual property. Given the heightened cybersecurity threats environment, companies need to upgrade existing controls in anticipation of worst case scenarios. In this area, IA will be significant in evaluating the company’s information security programs, the adequacy of the company’s incident-handling process in identifying potential vulnerabilities and threats, and the management of access to critical information and privacy.
KEEPING PACE – IA OF THE FUTURE
IA is only one of many business functions now being transformed by data, technology and innovation. Automation frees up resources so that they may be put to better use. While having in-house IA knowledge of technology generally makes operational sense, applying strategic partnerships to areas such as data analytics and robotics may yield better results.
IA leaders can continue to stay relevant to stakeholders and drive effectiveness and efficiencies for the company by rethinking audit delivery through investment in digital enablers such as RPA and optimizing the use of analytics in execution. The rise of new audit topics and the application of new tools require reinventing the future of talent as well. The required skills of an IA professional will now shift from pure audit expertise to those that address industry insight, technology advancement, and cultural adaptation. IA leaders should align these skillsets when recruiting new talent. While some skills may be developed internally, companies can also consider tapping an external flexible work force using co-source consultants or external subject matter resources so that internal talents can be refocused to higher impact audits.
IA must balance its priorities and resources to help organizations address the risks companies face today, anticipate emerging risks and stay in or ahead of the game. IA needs to adapt to today’s rapidly changing business environment and leverage on the newest developments in order to stay ahead of the curve. To give an old saying a new twist — necessity, after all, is the mother of reinvention.
This article is for general information only and is not a substitute for professional advice where the facts and circumstances warrant. The views and opinion expressed above are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of SGV & Co.
Christiane Joymiel C. Say-Mendoza is an Advisory Partner of SGV & Co.
Philippine PMI gains further momentum in November
By Melissa Luz T. Lopez, Senior Reporter
PHILIPPINE manufacturing activity further picked up steam in November to post the biggest surge this year on the back of strong demand for products both locally and abroad, according to monthly tracking done by IHS Markit for Nikkei, Inc.
The seasonally adjusted Nikkei Philippines Manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI) picked up to 54.8 in November from 53.7 the previous month, signaling “further improvement in business conditions” amid production expansion and new orders.
A PMI reading above 50 suggests improvement in business conditions compared to the previous month, while a score below that signals deterioration.
“The latest reading was also the highest so far this year,” read the report on the Philippines, citing expansion in output and new orders. “Anecdotal evidence suggested that strong economic conditions, promotional activity and greater client demand continued to sustain order book growth.”
Higher export demand for Philippine products gave a boost to the already upbeat orders from the domestic market, the PMI report added. This comes ahead of the expected surge in demand in time for Christmas.
Factories also hired more workers to take on additional workload ahead of the holiday season, as well as to address backlogs. November marks the third straight month of improving operating conditions, and hinted at stronger industrial activity during the fourth quarter.
The manufacturing PMI is composed of five sub-indices, with new orders having the biggest weight at 30%, followed by output (25%), employment (20%), suppliers’ delivery times (15%) and stocks of purchases (10%).
The monthly data is culled from replies to questionnaires sent to purchasing executives of 350 industrial companies. “Factories stepped up their purchasing activity to meet current and future demand. The rise in buying levels was the greatest since December last year,” the report added.
PMI growth logged 55.7 in December 2016.
More upbeat factory activity came despite “intensified” inflation pressures, although businesses remain optimistic even as prices of raw materials are on the rise. The central bank pegged November inflation between 2.9-3.6% in November, coming from the previous month’s 3.5%.
Still, manufacturing firms expect greater output in the coming months, signaling that they grew “more confident” about future business prospects.
Bernard Aw, principal economist at IHS Markit, said the latest PMI readings suggest that the industry will see its “strongest quarter for 2017.”
“Furthermore, there are signs in the latest survey sub-indices to suggest the upturn will gather pace in December,” Mr. Aw said in a statement. “The PMI suggests the strong growth momentum in the Filipino economy has some way to go.”
However, Mr. Aw noted that rising prices of raw materials and basic goods remain a concern for companies, coupled with a weaker peso, could result in an “unwelcome tightening” of profit margins.
Security Bank economist Angelo B. Taningco said broad business confidence among domestic and foreign markets drove stronger demand for local products, noting robust PMI figures provide assurance that economic growth will remain buoyant.
“The positive performance of manufacturing certainly bodes well for the Philippines’ GDP growth, which I think will likely stay above 6% in the fourth quarter,” Mr. Taningco said via e-mail. “However, its buoyant activity in November alone is not enough for GDP growth to reach 7% or higher; I think this has to be supported by improvements in the output activity of both agriculture and services sectors.”
Philippine gross domestic product expanded by 6.9% during the third quarter, beating market expectations and bringing the nine-month tally to 6.7%. This compares to the 6.5-7.5% growth goal set by the Duterte administration for the full year.
DoF sees November inflation easing to 3.2%
INFLATION likely eased in November, as stable food prices are seen to offset higher fuel costs and electricity rates, the Department of Finance (DoF) said on Friday.
In an economic bulletin, the DoF said inflation likely came in at 3.2% last month, lower than the 3.5% in October, which was the fastest in three years. The November print would be higher than the 2.5% recorded during the same month in 2016.
The DoF’s forecast falls within the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas’ 2.9-3.6% forecast range announced earlier this week.
The DOF projected the increase in prices of food and non-alcoholic beverages slowed to 2.9% in November from October’s 3.6%, while alcoholic beverages and tobacco dropped to 6.2% from 6.8%.
However, prices for housing, utilities and fuels subgroup likely grew by 4.2%, from the previous month’s 4%, while furnishings, household equipment increased by 1.9% from October’s 1.8%.
The DoF also cited the higher electricity rates and retail pump prices. Manila Electric Co.’s (Meralco) rate per kilowatt hour (kwh) for a household consuming 200 kilowatts per month increased by 35 centavos to P9.63 in November.
The price of diesel per liter in the National Capital Region went up to P35.37 last month from P34.51 in October. Gasoline prices, on the other hand, rose to P48.44 per liter in November from P46.89 per liter in the previous month.
“Adequate supply of goods from higher production will further dampen inflation rise in the future. This will likewise temper the rise in interest rates despite the ongoing [US Federal Reserve] tightening,” the DoF said in a statement.
The Philippine Statistics Authority will report November inflation data on Tuesday.
Overall commodity price increases averaged 3.2% in the ten months to October. — K.A.N. Vidal
House to give in to Senate’s version of the 2018 national budget
IT WILL only be a matter of time before the House of Representatives comes around to approving the adjustments made by the Senate in the 2018 national budget.
Several senators expressed these sentiments on Friday, with one even downplaying the possibility of next year’s national budget being re-enacted, a move that may prevent programs from receiving increased funding.
“Why don’t you just watch it because they’ll give in,” Senator Juan Edgardo M. Angara said in Filipino, reacting to an earlier statement made by Speaker Pantaleon D. Alvarez, who said that the House “already agreed to take a hard stance” on the matter. The House leader also said that the chamber was willing to risk re-enacting the 2017 budget.
“Styles of negotiating differ from person to person,” Mr. Angara continued in Filipino. “With my lengthy experience in politics, I’ve seen those who talk tough who also give in at the end of the day.”
Asked if he wished for the Senate version to prevail, Sen. Angara said: “That’s our mandate as the Senate panel. We have to argue for the Senate version because that’s what the senators voted on. But given the reality, we cannot insist on it if there is no agreement.”
For his part, Sen. Ralph Recto downplayed the possibility of a reenacted budget.
“That’s not good for the country,” said Mr. Recto, a member of the Senate bicameral conference panel on the proposed 2018 budget. “It will be a P300-billion less budget, so I don’t expect a reenacted budget. Don’t take too much out of it. I’m confident that there will be an agreement.” Among the contentious provisions from the Senate’s 2018 budget version are the P50 billion budget cut for the Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) over issues of right-of-way acquisitions. That version also realigned P900 million for police and military housing, which was previously allotted for Oplan Double Barrel, the police’s war on illegal drugs.
The House has deliberated thoroughly on its proposed budget so it is not just going to relent to the demands of some senators, Speaker Alvarez said.
House appropriations committee chair Rep. Karlo Alexei B. Nograles said that the chamber will deliberate on the amendments the Senate made on the 2018 budget.
“We will not concur,” Mr. Nograles said. “We will talk about this. We will not just concur and concur.” — Minde Nyl R. dela Cruz and Arjay L. Balinbin
Nothing wrong with President declaring a revolutionary government, DoJ Secretary says
JUSTICE Secretary Vitaliano N. Aguirre II emphasized that there is nothing wrong with President Rodrigo R. Duterte declaring a Revolutionary Government, a day after several rallies organized to support the move fizzled out due to the lack of attendees.
“There is nothing wrong with that,” Mr. Aguirre told reporters in an interview after the launch of Uniform Manual on Time Allowances and Services of Sentence on Friday. “In other words, we are free to express our opinion.”
He added: “There are people who believe that a revolutionary government will hasten reforms that’s why all of us have the right to express our own opinion.”
However, a statement released by Presidential Spokesperson Harry L. Roque Jr., said that the President has already ruled out a revolutionary government.
“The President has earlier said that he does not want a revolutionary government,” Mr. Roque said. “This, however, does not mean he would prevent citizens from expressing their support for a revolutionary government,” he added. — Andrea San Juan
8990 targets P60B in sales from 5 projects
By Arra B. Francia, Reporter
MASS housing developer 8990 Holdings, Inc. is looking to generate P60 billion in sales from five new projects to be launched next year.
“We’re looking at five new projects in 2018. Two in Visayas, with one in Iloilo, one is in Cebu, and two more in Davao, and a very big project in Ortigas,” 8990 Chief Operating Officer Willibaldo J. Uy told reporters after the listing ceremony of its P5-billion preferred shares on Friday.
8990 Chairman Mariano D. Martinez noted the company is currently in the process of securing permits for these projects, which are now “coming out in a more predictable manner.”
The listed property developer has previously encountered delays in getting permits, resulting to a slowdown in construction during the first half of 2017.
“To begin the process of getting approvals from the day you buy the property. You buy that property, ipasok mo na agad, para di ka maghintay nang matagal,” Mr. Martinez said.
Mr. Uy said the company has launched all of its projects for 2017, and is now working to speed up production.
With this, the company is targeting to hit the lower end of its P10 billion to P13 billion revenue guidance, with bottomline expected to come in at P4 billion or 40% of the revenue target.
8990 has so far booked a net income of P2.47 billion in the first nine months of 2017, 22% lower year-on-year, as delays in project launches pulled down earnings until the first half of the year.
Despite the lower profits so far this year, Mr. Martinez is confident 2017 “will still be a banner year for 8990.”
“We actually doubled what we made in the first semester, from P3 billion (revenues in the first half), it became P6.1 billion by the end of the third quarter. As far as sales take-up is concerned, I think once the buyer sees the buildings being put up, sales increase,” Mr. Uy added.
Meanwhile, 8990 said its P5-billion preferred shares offering on Friday was more than 1.3 times oversubscribed. The offer comprised 50 million preferred shares priced at P100 each, with a dividend rate of 6.0263% per annum, redeemable on the fifth anniversary of its listing date.
The company will be using the proceeds to pay off existing debt. It tapped ChinaBank Capita Corp to be the sole issue manager, lead underwriter, and book runner for the offer.
8990 is also currently awaiting approval from the Securities and Exchange Commission for its P10-billion shelf registration.
“Not sure yet when exactly next year, but it will happen next year. Most of the borrowings we get are usually to pare down debt,” Mr. Martinez said.
Shares in 8990 added five centavos or 0.91% apiece to close at P5.55 each at the stock exchange on Friday.
PhilWeb gets Pagcor nod to operate
PHILWEB Corp. has received the go-signal from the Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corp. (PAGCOR) to restart operations, the company disclosed to the stock exchange on Friday.
PhilWeb said it has received a letter from Pagcor last Nov. 29, saying it can resume operations as an electronic gaming system service (EGSS) provider to the first 16 PAGCOR-licensed gaming sites for electronic games.
Philweb’s operations will be subjected to further inspection and testing by PAGCOR.
The decision comes less than a month after PAGCOR stopped Philweb from resuming operations, until the agency procures a third party audit service provider for electronic games or Electronic Management Gaming System (EMGS).
To recall, Philweb had announced last October 30 that it received an accreditation from PAGCOR as an EGSS provider for PAGCOR-licensed electronic gaming sites. PAGCOR then had to clarify that the accreditation alone does not grant Philweb permission to conduct operations.
“Philweb, as well as other accredited electronic games providers, have to wait for PAGCOR’s Notice to Proceed before they can commence operations,” PAGCOR said earlier this month.
An EMGS is tasked to oversee the that all gaming service providers comply with existing regulations, while ensuring the accuracy of information provided by licensees and operators.
“With the EGMS in place, PAGCOR can be assured that all its electronic gaming licensees and operators are not only properly regulated but also accurately remit what is due to the government,” PAGCOR said in its earlier statement.
PAGCOR in August last year denied Philweb’s application to renew its license, following President Rodrigo R. Duterte’s sentiments against online gaming at the time, as well as his singling out of its former chairman Roberto V. Ongpin as an “oligarch.”
Mr. Ongpin then chose to divest his stake in the company worth P2 billion in favor of its current chairman, Gregorio Ma. Araneta III in October last year.
Philweb booked a net loss attributable to the parent of P206 million by the end of the third quarter of 2017, still reeling from the loss of its contract with PAGCOR.
Shares in Philweb jumped 1.47% or 13 centavos each to P8.98 at the end of trading on Friday. — Arra B. Francia
Speaker calls on Chief Justice to attend House impeachment hearing
SPEAKER Pantaleon D. Alvarez called on Chief Justice (CJ) Maria Lourdes P. A Sereno before the House justice committee investigation on her impeachment, instead of defending herself in the media.
Mr. Alvarez made these remarks after the chief magistrate attended public engagements including a mass at the Parish of Holy Sacrifice in Quezon City and a youth forum in the University of the Philippines where she insisted that she had done nothing wrong and that she will not step down from her post.
During the Nov. 29 proceedings in the House of Representatives, Associate Justice Teresita Leonardo De Castro confirmed allegations that Ms. Sereno altered a temporary restraining order (TRO) and created the Judicial Decentralized Office in Region 7 as opposed to the resolution earlier agreed on by the members of the high court.
“This is the reason why she really needs to attend [the House committee hearing] to disprove [these] allegations and the evidence that was presented against her,” Mr. Alvarez said in Filipino.
Meanwhile, Akbayan Rep. Tomasito S. Villarin described Justice De Castro’s appearance in the House investigation as a “charade.”
“She has angsts against CJ Sereno since the latter was appointed chief justice and not her,” Rep. Villarin said.
The lawmaker alleged that the associate justice has “made it her crusade to villify CJ Sereno inside and outside the Court.”
Rep. Villarin added: “Her disposition shows bias and emotion-laden statements. She clearly has an axe to grind against her primus inter pares (senior) in the Supreme Court.”
“I believe that this charade is heading nowhere but to a ‘monumental f*ck up’ that the House should immediately dismiss so we can tackle other important business like the BBL (Bangsamoro Basic Law) and other priority legislation,” the lawmaker said. — Minde Nyl R. Dela Cruz
LRWC subsidiary to obtain P2.5B loan from BDO
A UNIT of Leisure and Resorts World Corp. (LRWC) will be taking out a P2.5-billion loan from BDO Unibank, Inc. to partially finance its planned resort development.
In a disclosure to the stock exchange on Friday, the listed firm said its wholly-owned subsidiary AB Leisure Global, Inc. has executed an omnibus loan and security agreement (OLSA) with the Sy-led bank.
“The OLSA was executed to fund the acquisition of parcels of land for its planned resort development,” the company said in the disclosure.
LRWC did not include further details about the resort project.
Incorporated in 1957, LRWC and its subsidiaries operate internet and gaming enterprises in the Cagayan Special Economic Zone Free Port. It further develops leisure properties in the country.
LRWC profits declined 59% in the first nine month of 2017 to P362 million, following a 10% year-on-year drop in revenues to P7.3 billion.
Shares in LRWC were down by 2.45% or nine centavos to close at P3.59 apiece on Friday. — Arra B. Francia
Philippines, Singapore team up for aircraft surveillance technology in Palawan
THE Philippines and Singapore will be unveiling new surveillance technology in Palawan to monitor flights and improve air traffic management.
In a statement released on Friday by the Department of Transportation, the Civil Aviation Authority of the Philippines (CAAP) and the Civil Aviation Authority of Singapore (CAAS) will inaugurate the Automatic Dependent Surveillance Broadcast (ADS-B) on Saturday in Bataraza, Palawan.
The ADS-B collaboration, which tracks aircraft through satellite navigation, will also give CAAS access to ADS-B data among other services. Likewise, the satellite can also provide the right altitude for aircraft to reduce their carbon footprint.
Data received through the satellite, including velocity, altitude, and its identity, are gathered every two seconds and will then be sent to CAAP’s air traffic control center.
“Aside from enhancing the safety and efficiency of air traffic services, ADS-B also improves the ability to perform life-saving search and rescue missions. It can provide more accurate information about last reported positions, minimizing the search period, in such operations,” the statement read. — Anna G. A. Mogato
Operational lapses caused BPI system glitch — BSP
By Melissa Luz T. Lopez, Senior Reporter
THE CENTRAL BANK has found operational lapses that led to a two-day internal glitch at the Bank of the Philippine Islands (BPI) last June, a senior official said, as the regulator completes its investigation into the incident.
The Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) is still determining whether it would impose sanctions on the lender, Deputy Governor Chuchi G. Fonacier told reporters in an ambush interview.
“The BSP investigation is complete… We’re still having this internal meeting before we elevate [to the Monetary Board],” Ms. Fonacier said, noting that the central bank will release a public statement on their final decision involving the Ayala-led lender.
The Monetary Board is the highest decision-making body in the BSP, which sets regulatory standards and hands out penalties if deemed necessary.
BPI encountered a two-day downtime in its online and automated teller machine platforms after an internal error resulted in incorrect account balances reflected in about 1.5 million customer accounts on June 7-8.
It took the bank around 37 hours to correct the account balances, which saw some P46 million mistakenly withdrawn from bank accounts. BPI officials have dubbed the incident as an “internal data processing error” due to human error, as it dismissed fears that the bank’s systems have been hacked.
BPI is the country’s fourth-biggest bank in asset terms. It reported a P17.05 billion net income as of end-September as loans grew by a fifth to reach P1.12 trillion.
On Tuesday, the BSP announced a set of sanctions imposed on Metropolitan Bank & Trust Co. (Metrobank) over the P1.75-billion internal fraud case unearthed in July. The central bank reprimanded bank directors and officers, and handed 90-day suspensions to top officials including President Fabian S. Dee and Vicente R. Cuna, Jr. of the Philippine Savings Bank, who was previously head of Metrobank’s corporate banking group.
The BSP also asked Metrobank to set aside P4.45 billion in additional capital to cover for “higher operational risk” after internal checks and balances failed to detect the bogus loans in multiple tranches worth P30 million, which reportedly allowed bank vice president Maria Victoria S. Lopez to pocket the money.
The central bank has been raising its standards to manage operational risks, as it seeks to fortify the banking system.
