By Dave Cook
The economist John Maynard Keynes predicted in 1930 that the amount we work would gradually shrink to as little as 15 hours a week as technology made us more productive. Not only did this not happen, but we also began to spend extra time away from home due to commuting and suburban living patterns, which we often forget are recent historical inventions.
However, 2020 has changed all that. In my new history of remote work during COVID-19, I marvel at how much it has shaken up our lives and how much we took for granted. My research also points to a number of trends that will help shape working life in 2021.
OVER ‘IN TIME FOR CHRISTMAS’
At the start of 2020 remote work was a gradually rising long-term trend. Only 12% of workers in the US worked remotely full time, 6% in the UK. Naturally, the world was unprepared for mass remote work.
But COVID-19 instantly proved remote work was possible for many people. Workplace institutions and norms toppled like dominos. The office, in-person meetings, and the daily commute fell first. Then the nine-to-five schedule, vacations, and private home lives were threatened. Countries even started issuing remote work visas to encourage people to spend lockdown working in their territory.
As old norms vanished, a rapid procession of novel technologies marched uninvited into our homes. We had to master Zoom meeting etiquette, compassionate e-mail practices, navigate surveillance, juggle caring responsibilities. The list goes on.
In the face of grim statistics—the United Nations predicted 195 million job losses—only the tone-deaf complained about working from home. Nonetheless, COVID-19 created the biggest remote work experiment in human history.
In July, UK prime minister Boris Johnson—with Edwardian optimism—daydreamed a sense of normality would return “in time for Christmas.” Fast forward through summer to lockdown 2.0 and the fantasy of a 12-week experiment faded into sepia-tinged memories. One interviewee joked: “I really thought we’d be back in the office by July, what fools we were!”
ARE YOU DISCIPLINED?
Silicon Valley companies Google, Apple, and Twitter were among the first to announce employees could work from home. Ahead of the curve, they were well practiced. Predictably, they already had a fancy term for it: distributed working. In 2021 concepts such as distributed and hybrid working will proliferate.
Most were less prepared than Silicon Valley. In March, I published findings from a four-year research study tracking remote workers. I warned, to be a successful remote worker deep reserves of self-discipline were required, otherwise burnout followed.
We understand this now. But I spent the first lockdown patiently explaining to news outlets why working from home was so hard. When I suggested returning to the office might be considered a luxury—because it helped people structure their days—a news presenter laughed. For good or ill, conversations about disciplined routines will intensify in 2021.
By May 2020 many reported experiencing Zoom fatigue. I naively predicted Zoom use would subside.
I’d have been right if we’d returned to the office. Instead, necessity dictated we up our Zoom game—even if they were draining. Zoom simultaneously saved and ruined working from home, and it’s not going away anytime soon.
THE COMMUTING PARADOX
Remote workers, grateful to still have jobs, also reported a gnawing sense of survivors’ guilt. Overwork was one way of expressing this guilt. Many felt working extra hours might secure their job.
In April 2020, I joined other academics researching work-life balance on a project called eWorkLife. The research data revealed increases in working hours when it wasn’t obvious when the working day ended. Especially with no obvious signal to end the working day.
In my four-year remote study, I had noticed a strange pattern. Participants initially said “escaping the commute” was a key benefit of remote working. Yet months later these same workers started recreating mini commutes.
The eWorkLife project uncovered similar findings. People wanted to create “a clear division between work and home.” Study lead Prof. Anna Cox urged people to do pretend commutes so they could maintain a work-life balance. In 2021, work-life balance must become recognized as a public health issue and the eWorkLife project is urging policy makers to act.
THE RIGHT TO DISCONNECT
What’s happened to the time previously lost to commuting? Many are using it to catch up on admin and e-mail. This taps into a worrying trend.
Pre-pandemic warnings about an encroaching 24/7 work culture were intensifying. Social scientists argued that contemporary workers were being turned into worker-smartphone hybrids. In 2016, French workers were even given the legal right to disconnect from work e-mail outside working hours.
A hopeful wish list for 2021 includes continued increases in workplace activism and for companies and governments to reveal their remote working policies. Twitter and 17 other companies have already announced employees can work remotely indefinitely. At least 60% of US companies still haven’t shared their remote working policies with their employees. Remote workers tell me until bosses reveal their post-pandemic policies—planning for their future is impossible.
The late activist David Graeber described the failure to achieve Keynes’s 15-hour workweek as a missed opportunity, “a scar across our collective soul”. COVID-19 may have started conversations about alternative futures where work and leisure are better balanced.
But it won’t come easily. And we will have to fight for it. — The Conversation
Dave Cook is a PhD candidate in Anthropology at University College London.