Home Blog Page 8588

Buy now, pay whenever? Lockdown lift for online shopping loans

BROWSING online during lockdown, Jessica Friend spotted a pair of Ray-Ban sunglasses she liked, but the price tag made the 30-year-old Ohio resident think twice.

What persuaded her to click “buy,” Ms. Friend said, was the short-term credit offered by Afterpay, which split the $260 payment into four interest-free instalments.

Afterpay is among a handful of alternative credit firms which offer small loans, mostly to online shoppers, and make their money by charging merchants a 4%-6% commission.

These buy-now-pay-later (BNPL) firms have benefited from a shift to online shopping during the coronavirus crisis in countries including the United States, where state aid has also boosted retail sales.

“I’m more inclined to use them because they make it easier to afford to get the things I want all at once … and when I want to splurge on something,” Ms. Friend said of the loans.

Some investors are now betting shoppers will stay away from stores as coronavirus cases rise again in several countries around the world, boosting business for BNPL firms.

But swelling subscriber numbers may also increase bad loans, mainly among first-time users who are more likely to default.

And as job losses rise and government aid ebbs, the business model will face its first real test in a recession.

“Much still hinges on any virus second waves and government wherewithal to keep boosting demand,” said Andrew Mitchell of Ophir Asset Management which owns shares in Melbourne-based Afterpay, whose market value has risen to $12.55 billion from over $100 million four years ago.

While a move to online shopping was underway before the pandemic, the shift has accelerated under lockdown and Afterpay signed up more than a million new active US customers between March and early May, taking its overall base there to 9 million.

Meanwhile retailers desperate to move merchandise have also become more receptive to partnerships with BNPL firms, which unlike credit cards or mortgages, make loans instantly.

Klarna, Europe’s biggest fintech startup, said that since March enquiries from retailers who may want to partner with it jumped by 20% on average globally.

With 7.9 million US subscribers, Sweden’s Klarna has since signed up outdoor gearmaker The North Face, Disney’s streaming service and cosmetics retailer Sephora.

Most of the growth has been in higher-margin discretionary spend categories such as fashion and fitness gear, said Puneet Dikshit, a McKinsey partner in New York, who expects the sector to generate $7 billion to $8 billion in volumes this year in the United States, growing by more than 150% annually. — Reuters

Alcoholic drinks now allowed at dine-in restaurants

Restaurants with dine-in operations are required to follow minimum health standards prescribed by the government. — REUTERS

RESTAURANTS with dine-in operations will now be allowed to serve each customer up to two alcoholic beverages, the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) said.

DTI Memorandum Circular 20-39 issued on July 17 officially increases the dine-in cap to 50% for areas under general community quarantine (GCQ) and 75% to areas under modified general community quarantine (MGCQ) starting on July 21. Metro Manila is currently under GCQ.

Restaurants and fastfood establishments are allowed to serve all types of food and beverages, but alcoholic beverages are limited to two individual servings per customer.

Buffet services are allowed if there are food servers and covers for the food trays.

Families living in the same household may dine together in one table that is separated at least one meter from other customers’ tables. The family must show proof that they stay in one address.

The establishments may operate up to 11 p.m. daily.

“(Local government units) are enjoined to adjust curfew hours up to 12 midnight to allow greater daily turnover of dine-in services and enhance income opportunities for workers,” the memorandum said.

Establishments primarily serving alcohol, such as bars, are not allowed to operate, according to a resolution from the Inter-Agency Task Force on Emerging Infectious Diseases (IATF).

Most cities have lifted their respective liquor bans. Makati City has approved an ordinance banning individuals from drinking liquor outside of their residence during a state of calamity or public health emergency.

Restaurants with dine-in operations are required to follow minimum health standards prescribed by the government, including registration with Safepass or staysafe.ph, distribution of contact tracing forms, thermal scanning of all personnel, suppliers, and customers, and provision for sanitizers.

DTI also requires establishments to improve their exhaust system, implement a “no face mask, no entry” policy, and implement physical distancing.

DTI also asks establishments to minimize music to discourage loud talking, “which increases the likelihood of droplet transmission.”

Establishments are also encouraged to adopt additional measures, including installing air purifiers and acrylic dividers at least 18-inches high for face-to-face seating.

Various government agencies, including the Trade, Health, Tourism, and Labor departments, may conduct restaurant inspections.

Establishments that do not comply with the health guidelines after a warning may be temporarily closed down.

Barbershops and salons may also operate with up to 50% of their capacity for GCQ areas and 75% for MGCQ areas. — Jenina P. Ibañez

Embracing digital, hoping for stimulus — and waiting for transport to normalize

By Charmaine A. Tadalan, Reporter

THE fitful resumption of bricks-and-mortar business and the cost of installing new safety measures have left companies no choice but to embrace the tricky double act of plunging headlong into contactless sales methods, while ensuring supply and transport disruptions don’t shut them down.

But beyond what they can do to help themselves, they are also counting on outside intervention — in the form of the stimulus packages currently awaiting passage in Congress. The return of something as mundane as buses on the road would also be nice.

Paul A. Santos, chairman of the Philippine Retailers Association and president of the Picture City chain of photography stores, said building confidence and minimizing face-to-face interactions are the main task for companies.

“In the short term, it is the industry’s mission to restore confidence in consumers and employees that shopping and working in-store is as safe as circumstances will allow,” Mr. Santos said in an e-mail.

“Going into the medium-term, it must accelerate the adoption of techniques that will fulfill shopper’s needs and wants, and yet minimize, if not eliminate, points of contact with humans in the purchasing cycle — the age of contactless commerce, of which e-commerce is just one of the methods.”

Mr. Santos said industry is complying with the health recommendations of the government and the medical community, including face masks, distancing and disinfection.

“At the same time, retailers are rapidly adopting contactless commerce techniques, and one of them, which is contactless payments, is by far the easiest to implement,” he said.

“E-commerce, however, is also sought after, because it creates an entirely new goods distribution channel and at the same time it has the potential for creating synergies with retailers’ bricks-and-mortar assets.”

During the lockdown, e-commerce allowed retailers to reach their customers via delivery and in-store pickup.

Mr. Santos said physical stores may soon implement a semi- or fully automated checkout system or even develop an artificial and virtual reality system for certain activities like clothes fitting or cosmetics sampling.

The digital transformation, however, must also allow for worst-case scenarios like a second-wave outbreak.

“To prepare for this eventuality, retailers must formulate continuity of business operations plans, which should include boosting online distribution efforts,” he said.

“Also, retailers must be ready to move essential back-office functions, like inventory, purchasing, financial management, and human relations to the cloud, to permit work-from-home operations.”

SUPPLY CHAINS
The British Chamber of Commerce of the Philippines (BCCP) said digitalization is considered central to any business recovery, and that extends to gaining some control over vulnerable supply chains, Executive Director Chris Nelson said in a phone interview.

The chamber has over 300 members, consisting of multinationals as well as small- and medium-sized businesses, which Mr. Nelson said the BCCP is more concerned about.

“I think the internet and digital will be critical to companies,” he said, with many members adopting work-from-home arrangements and leaving e-commerce to do the heavy lifting on sales. His caveat was the need for added vigilance on security of company systems.

In addition, Mr. Nelson also said companies will be focusing on improving supply chains and points of vulnerability.

“There will be a review of supply chains — how they can get things closer or shorter… and how can they then distribute to their business and partners,” he said, noting that speedy and reliable delivery will be a competitive advantage.

“This is a very unusual economic crisis… it’s a crisis where people couldn’t go out or are very restricted on how they can go out and therefore, for many people, home is where you can reach them.”

Francis del Val of Cobena Business Analytics and Strategy, Inc. said companies that can go digital are more likely to stay afloat.

“What’s going to be the key to be able to survive and thrive in this new normal is digital transformation,” Mr. Del Val said during the BusinessWorld Insights forum on June 10.

“Businesses that are digital are going to be more successful because they are going to be more productive, more efficient and profitable.”

WHERE GOVERNMENT SUPPORT COMES IN
Mr. Nelson said beyond what companies can do for themselves, the government’s actions will also be key in ensuring a smooth restart to the economy. He identified as most critical among the pending measures the P1.3-trillion stimulus package targeted mainly at micro-, small-, and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs).

“The public and the private sector have to work together in order to avoid a deep recession and the impact on unemployment and economically challenged families,” he said.

“I think that will be as critical as the recovery strategies of the company.”

The measure he was referring to is House Bill No. 6815, the “Accelerated Recovery and Investments Stimulus for the Economy of the Philippines Act,” which will provide P50 billion in loans to MSMEs in 2020 and beyond.

“We understand constraints, but stimulus needs to be done now as quickly as possible in order to ensure that the economy has a V-shaped recovery.”

The bill was passed by the House of Representatives, but remains pending at the Senate.

PUBLIC TRANSPORT
Philippine Exporters Confederation, Inc. Vice Chairman George T. Barcelon concurred, saying: “I hope the money is channeled to MSMEs so that they can afford to get their people back to work and at the same time, start economic activity.”

Mr. Barcelon said exporters were hit hard by the lockdown and have not yet returned to their pre-pandemic levels of activity.

“The industry has been affected badly for eight weeks of whatever form of lockdown. Even now, we still don’t have public transportation and that is what has affected businesses,” he said.

Mr. Barcelon said the three major factors businesses need to recover — market demand, mobility of the workforce and supply chain efficiency.

The Inter-Agency Task Force running the government’s pandemic response allowed a phased-in resumption of public transportation, with trains, taxis, and shuttle services returning on June 1-21. During that same period, no provincial buses were allowed to enter Metro Manila.

Public utility buses, modern jeeps and UV Express units, meanwhile, were allowed to resume in the second phase starting June 22-30.

Mr. Barcelon added that companies are expected to work out with financial institutions how to extend loan deadlines and obtain credit to finance a return to operations.

“We’re in the planning stage right now and then also a lot of companies (are) short of financing and need to work out (funding) through their banks,” he said.

Mr. Barcelon’s recovery timeline for the economy is indefinite though he finds it unlikely to happen in the “next three months.

Debt service payments drop by 10% in May

THE government’s debt service bill declined by 10% in May, as both amortization and interest payments fell, the Bureau of the Treasury (BTr) reported.

Data from the BTr showed the National Government made debt payments worth P24.642 billion in May, down 10.09% from P27.407 billion paid in the same month last year. This was also lower than the debt service bill of P148.34 billion in April.

Interest payments made up 74.48% of the total, with 25.52% allocated for principal repayments.

For amortization, the government allotted P6.289 billion, lower by 18.73% from P7.738 billion a year ago. These were all paid to external creditors in May.

Interest payments also declined by 6.69% to P18.353 billion from P19.669 billion a year ago. Local lenders were paid P14.466 billion, broken down into P7.73 billion in interest payments for fixed-rate Treasury bonds, P4.86 billion for retail Treasury bonds and P1.876 billion for Treasury bills.

The remaining P3.887 billion went to interest payments to foreign lenders.

In five months to May, the government’s total debt service bill hit P512.96 billion. This is 49.54% of the programmed P1.033-trillion debt payments target for 2020, based on the Budget of Expenditures and Sources of Financing report.

This includes P352.845 billion in amortization and P160.115 billion in interest payments.

In 2019, total debt payments reached P842.449 billion, up 16.1% from P725.589 billion settled in 2018.

The government borrows from both domestic and foreign lenders to plug the budget deficit which is seen widening to 8.4-9% of gross domestic product this year as economic activity slows down amid the crisis.

Separately, BTr data showed gross borrowings reached P1.509 trillion from January to May, already exceeding the P1.02 trillion raised for full-year 2019.

Excluding the repayments made, net borrowings totaled P1.342 trillion during the five-month period.

The economic team projected that borrowings for this year will be higher than the initial plan to raise P1.4 trillion. However, there is no revised borrowing program released so far. — B.M.Laforga

World’s supply chain managers bask in their extended moment

ACCUSTOMED to crunch time and performing in a crisis, the world’s supply chain managers are having something of an extended moment in pandemic recovery mode.

Procurement experts were center stage in the rush to secure alternative sources of household essentials, medical gear, raw materials and components to keep factories running when COVID-19 first struck. Now chief executive officers are looking to those same managers for more strategic vision and ways to shock-proof supply chains for corporate survival.

From automakers to food processors, manufacturers that have relied on a strategy of low-cost supplies and minimum inventories are rethinking such an approach given the combination of the pandemic, trade conflicts and harsher natural disasters.

The buzzwords now are flexibility and resilience.

“This whole part of the equation has a higher prominence,” Alexander Lacik, CEO of Danish jeweler Pandora Group with about 7,400 outlets, said in an interview. The chief supply chain officer “is not someone I speak to just once a month,” he said.

When the coronavirus hit, it took some companies three to four weeks to understand the ripple effect on areas like procurement and logistics.

Those firms are now in the rebuilding phase, with one eye on what digital tools and other technology they need to stay on top when the next crisis comes, according to Kristian Park, a risk advisory partner at Deloitte in London.

“There’s been a 50% increase in people coming forward who have realized they didn’t have the information they needed,” Mr. Park said. “As always with these things, it takes one seismic shift to change people’s perception of the risks.”

That’s the sweet spot of a chief supply chain officer, who is typically more comfortable with a broad focus spanning procurement, logistics, strategic alliances and managing costs, Mr. Park said.

Recent studies support a move to introduce more flexibility. Companies with a resilient supply network grow faster because they better adapt to shifts in demand, potentially boosting their order rate by as much as 40% and customer satisfaction by up to 30%, according to a study by Bain & Co.

Making its own jewelry in Thailand and owning shops across 100 countries means Pandora’s Chief Supply Officer Jeerasage Puranasamriddhi has greater control. Yet the company still relies on air freight and some 200 suppliers. As the pandemic snowballed, the company’s initial response was to push more inventory to its shop premises in case one of the large centralized warehouse facilities went down, Mr. Lacik said.

Mr. Lacik is now reviewing his company’s set-up, from procurement of materials to surging online sales. Where possible, having a single source for an input will be avoided and backup plans put in place. Online sales are up as much as 300% currently, leading the Danish company to rethink its e-commerce strategy, and whether it could manage online sales internally rather than rely on a third party. It may also look at factories outside of Thailand, Mr. Lacik said.

Two decades ago less than 10% of companies had a supply chain director, according to Jan Godsell, a professor of operations and supply chain strategy at the University of Warwick. The number now is closer to 50%, with the role of a chief supply chain officer becoming more common in the past five years.

They’re ascending the corporate ladder even more in the post-pandemic world, she said.

“COVID-19 may have been a wake-up call to main boards of the importance of supply chains and hopefully it will accelerate the rise of the chief supply chain officer,” Mr. Godsell said.

The median salary for a supply-chain manager was about $78,507 a year for those with a bachelor’s degree and $95,750 with a graduate degree or higher, according to the Association for Supply Chain Management’s 2020 annual survey. The poll generated about 2,500 responses through Jan. 31.

At large global companies, the top positions can pay $300,000 to $400,000.

But even before the health crisis, there were chronic shortages of workers to fill the positions — about one applicant for every six openings, says Abe Eshkenazi, CEO of the Chicago-based association.

As the jobs become a bigger part of a company’s strategic management team, he says more lucrative salaries will follow. “The demand for talent is going to be significant on the backside of this,” Mr. Eshkenazi says. “We’re seeing skills and expectations for supply chains increase exponentially.”

All the sudden interest hasn’t gone unnoticed among students facing a brutal job market. Haslam College of Business, part of the University of Tennessee in Knoxville, is among colleges offering supply chain studies that are seeing a flurry of inquiries from students and workers looking for a new career, according to George Drinnon, executive director of undergraduate programs. “This awareness is translating into more attention to the field,” he said.

Another anecdotal sign of the profession’s popularity: 6,000 registered attendees from 109 countries for a July 16-18 virtual conference titled “Preparing for the Recovery After Covid-19” and hosted by Alcott Global, an executive search firm specializing in e-commerce, logistics and supply chain executives.

Speakers include the supply chain bosses from companies including Swedish appliance maker Electrolux AB, US tool maker Stanley Black & Decker Inc. and Beiersdorf AG, the German maker of Nivea skin-care products. The Singapore-based recruiter sold out of sponsorships for the event in 10 days.

“We are seeing huge interest,” said Radu Palamariu, Alcott’s managing director for Asia-Pacific. — Bloomberg

Japan is figuring out how to deliver goods untouched by humans

GETTING PRODUCTS from one place to another with as little human contact as possible is becoming an imperative for businesses as retailers, warehouses and transport providers adapt to the coronavirus pandemic, seeking to minimize the risk of infections to their employees and customers.

Tsubakimoto Chain Co. is seeing more demand for its sorting and conveyor systems as companies seek ways to move things around, while startup Hacobu sees an opportunity to boost use of its online platform for trucks to exchange information as they load and unload goods at warehouses, a process that’s still mostly done on paper.

The need for automation is especially acute in Japan, where a labor shortage was already putting pressure on companies to find ways to run their businesses with fewer people. Now, that transition is being spurred on by the pandemic, which has boosted online buying and raised concerns among shoppers about being infected by items delivered to their doors. All told, the market for next-generation logistics systems in Japan is set to more than double to 651 billion yen ($6 billion) through 2025 from 2018, according to researcher Fuji Keizai.

“Demand for humanless systems will keep growing,” Masafumi Okamoto, division manager at Osaka-based Tsubakimoto, said in an e-mail. More families are turning to electronic commerce to buy household goods, and the manufacturer is getting more inquiries for its automated equipment, he said.

Daifuku Co., an 83-year-old company that makes and sells material-handling equipment, has seen its shares climb. Its market capitalization topped 1 trillion yen in mid-May.

“Daifuku will lead the way to a new normal in the post-COVID era,” said Toshiharu Morita, an analyst at SBI Securities. “Its visibility for mid- and long-term growth is high,” he said, adding that Daifuku is one of the top global players in the industry with its solid technology.

Above Robotics, a San Francisco-based startup, offers services to stitch together various autonomous logistics and transportation systems. Its cloud-based software can get shipping companies, warehouses and driverless vehicles to communicate directly and handle goods with fewer humans in between. Above Robotics has had inquiries from companies in Japan, South Korea and other parts of Asia, according to Dirk Beth, a director at the company.

“We’re certainly seeing an acceleration of interest because of COVID,” Mr. Beth said. “I don’t think that’s going to slow down even if the COVID situation is solved today, because now what companies are thinking is, ‘when is the next time this is going to happen and people can’t go to work? How do we make sure that our goods get to the end customer?’”

Hacobu, the logistics-data company, teamed up with Hino Motors Ltd. in May to solve issues such as a shortage of drivers. Japan has had a chronic insufficiency of drivers, with 85% of companies surveyed by the Japan Truck Association saying they didn’t have enough, according to a 2019 poll.

There are still a lot of areas where humans are needed in logistics facilities. If the number of staff in warehouses is restricted to prevent transmission of the COVID-19 pathogen, that could limit shipments and turn into lost sales opportunities, according to Takeshi Kitaura, an analyst at Bloomberg Intelligence.

“The incentives for automation have gone up,” Mr. Kitaura said. He predicts that many providers of automation machines will see a drop in demand from automakers as the pandemic depresses sales of automobiles across the globe, and that the transport and logistics sector could make up for that decline.

Japan’s bigger retailers are also looking to automate their operations. Rakuten, Inc. Chief Executive Officer Hiroshi Mikitani said in May that his online marketplace is automating its logistics and installing new machines to reduce manual labor. Tadashi Yanai of Fast Retailing Co. also said the maker of Uniqlo clothing is actively investing in logistics and its supply chain.

Mujin, Inc., a company that makes industrial robot controllers, said there’s booming interest for its solutions. Logistics automation is now seen as a way to prepare for emergency, said spokeswoman Yuzuki Ishihara.

Hisashi Taniguchi, CEO of ZMP, Inc., which makes driverless carts and forklifts for warehouses, said the number of clients using its machines to support logistics will increase by 150 to 200 this year. ZMP is now planning to list on the Tokyo Stock Exchange, after postponing it in 2016.

Japan’s government is also behind the push into logistics automation. The country needs to embrace the use of data and artificial intelligence in managing truck fleets, autonomous vehicles and drones to be more competitive globally, the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism said in a policy paper. For example, the agency called for the use of drones in less populated, mountainous areas.

“The big challenge for us is regulations, which are different all over the world” for new technology such as drones, said Mr. Beth of Above Robotics. — Bloomberg

Jobless recovery now a risk for Europe’s economy

WITH job cuts mounting and costly furlough programs that can’t last forever, Europe is at risk of a devastating increase in unemployment that won’t be easy to reverse.

Economies across the continent are recovering and company sentiment is brightening, but it’s a different story when it comes to hiring. After months of crisis, the outlook remains too uncertain for firms to commit to spending. Many may not even reinstate all furloughed workers when governments end subsidies that kept millions on payrolls.

All that raises the prospect of a job-poor — or even jobless — recovery, where unemployment stays high for a prolonged period even as growth appears to pick up. That could threaten consumer demand, hitting retailers, restaurants and bars that are already struggling, and feeding a damaging loop through the economy.

“The initial phase of the recovery will be jobless, and that’s very typical for a European recovery,” said Nick Kounis, an economist at ABN Amro. “A lot of the job losses are still ahead of us.”

The potentially bleak employment outlook for Europe underscores how even a combination of policies that generally set the continent apart both in halting the spread of the coronavirus and mitigating its economic fallout can’t ultimately completely protect labor markets.

In the euro area, unemployment could hit almost 10% by the end of the year as the economy slumps, according to a Bloomberg survey. A rebound in growth in 2021 won’t be enough to reverse the damage. UK joblessness is forecast to reach 8%, more than double its tally earlier this year.

Furlough schemes to subsidize payrolls in the euro zone’s four biggest economies supported 26 million people at their peak, according to Bloomberg Economics. But even with such huge programs, the fallout on jobs is spreading. In recent weeks, Airbus SE, Commerzbank AG and Sanofi were among major companies to signal staff cuts.

The situation could deteriorate further once furloughs are wound down. If business hasn’t recovered enough when that happens, dole lines will grow.

“The worst of the impact on labor markets may be yet to come,” European Central Bank Executive Board member Fabio Panetta said this month. “Some workers on short-time work schemes and temporary lay-offs may not be able to return to their jobs, and hiring looks likely to stay subdued.”

At Bank of America, analysts point to the European Commission’s monthly confidence data, where the job outlook in key economies is lagging that for industrial output.

“If production expectations improve more than employment expectations, the recovery may be job-poor, with implications for the labor market and household consumption,” economists including Ruben Segura-Cayuela and Evelyn Herrmann said in a report.

MAIN CONCERNS
That prospect is already troubling consumers. An Ipsos Mori poll covering 27 countries showed their second-biggest worry after the coronavirus was unemployment. In France, Italy and Spain, it’s the top concern, more even than the virus that killed almost 100,000 in those three nations.

Policy makers are acknowledging the dangers, highlighting issues such as scarring in the labor market as millions lose work.

“Layoffs in the wake of bankruptcies are likely to leave many jobseekers struggling to retain their skills and attachment to the labor market,” the European Commission warned on July 7.

The Bank of England also sees a threat of higher and more persistent unemployment. When its chief economist, Andy Haldane, offered a relatively optimistic take on the economy last month, it was tempered by labor-market worries.

“Of these risks, the most important to avoid is a repeat of the high and long-duration unemployment rates of the 1980s, especially among young people,” he said.

Governments are desperate to get ahead of the problem. UK Chancellor of the Exchequer Rishi Sunak announced a new program to protect jobs this month to counter what he described as “the most urgent challenge” of unemployment. That announcement came two days after an Opinium survey showed almost half of businesses expect to cut staff when Britain’s furlough program ends in October.

German politicians are currently discussing an extension of their own program, while France has created a furlough mechanism that could last up to two years for companies that strike deals with unions on reduced working time in exchange for job guarantees. The French government has also pledged an annual incentive of as much as 4,000 euros ($4,566) for hiring young people.

The costs of such measures are too high for politicians to make them permanent, even if central bank bond-buying stimulus has bought them room for maneuver by containing yields for now. Analysts also wonder if even all that support will be enough to mitigate permanent economic damage.

“For some industries, you can see structural changes which may mean that some jobs might not come back,” ABN’s Kounis said. “The people who are sometimes laid off in an industry that is downsizing don’t have the right skill sets straight away to fit into industries that are moving forward.” — Bloomberg

BusinessWorld’s 33rd Anniversary special issue

BUSINESSWORLD marks its 33rd anniversary as the world faces possibly the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression. The 11-section, 48-page anniversary issue contains special reporting on the coronavirus pandemic, its world-changing impact on society, and what the recovery might look like. BusinessWorld has also been keeping busy with online forums with some of the most authoritative voices in industry. For more content beyond the newspaper edition, please visit https://www.bworldonline.com/theroadtorecovery/ .

Telehealth’s long-term staying power

WHOEVER said “an apple a day keeps the doctor away” didn’t have a computer in mind. But with more Americans staying away from doctors’ offices because of COVID-19 (coronavirus disease 2019), the use of telehealth has been surging.

In the early stages of the pandemic, healthcare systems prioritized urgent medical issues and delayed optional care, leading to a 60% drop in outpatient visits in April.

Simultaneously, telemedicine visits surged by as much as 14%, according to data from Harvard University and Phreesia, a healthcare software company.

The move toward doing more health care online has helped squeeze the finances of many physician practices. Research from Health Affairs shows that US primary care offices could lose $15.1 billion in revenue this year due to COVID-19. While telehealth keeps medical practices working, it is generally not as lucrative — reimbursement rates from insurers are typically lower for online appointments.

While the US continues to thrust itself into reopening, in-person visits have begun to rise. Still, business remains slow, and telehealth is still being used more often than it ever was in the past.

But how accessible is telehealth for people who don’t have access to a stable internet connection, computers, or the ability to fix technology snags when they arise? For all its benefits in a pandemic, practicing medicine over the internet has pitfalls. — Bloomberg

US insurers use lofty estimates to beat back coronavirus claims

NEW YORK — US property and casualty insurers have cast the coronavirus pandemic as an unprecedented event whose massive cost to small businesses they are neither able nor required to cover.

The industry has warned it could cost them $255 billion to $431 billion a month if they are required, as some states are proposing, to compensate firms for income lost and expenses owed due to virus-led shutdowns, an amount it says would make insurers insolvent.

The estimate, made by the American Property Casualty Insurance Association (APCIA), a trade group, was recently used by the industry to successfully lobby against state and city lawmakers’ efforts to legislate to make the sector pay.

Insurers say business interruption policies only apply when actual physical property damage prevents a business from operating and any attempt to apply cover beyond that, for a pandemic, are unconstitutional.

The stance has discouraged some policyholders from filing claims and prompted others to take legal action.

A Reuters examination of APCIA’s estimate, however, suggests the possible bill may not be so onerous.

The APCIA estimate is an industry worst-case scenario based on all small firms with business interruption coverage being able to claim. It also assumes that between 60% and 90% of businesses with fewer than 100 employees will be impacted by COVID-19 (coronavirus disease 2019).

Only about 40% of small firms have business interruption coverage, according to the Insurance Information Institute, and most of the policies explicitly exclude pandemics, according to Tyler Leverty and Lawrence Powell, professors who specialize in insurance at the University of Wisconsin and the University of Alabama, respectively.

Powell has estimated that insurers could be on the hook for a maximum of $120 billion a month in claims on the basis that half of small firms have business interruption insurance.

Leverty said that if the estimate counted only businesses without explicit exclusions for pandemics, “it would be in the millions per month.”

The APCIA said it stood by its numbers, which it said reflect the unique and widespread impact of the virus. It declined to comment on Powell’s analysis.

“Yes, these are eye-popping figures,” APCIA Chief Executive David Sampson told Reuters, referring to the association’s estimate. “This pandemic is unprecedented in its scale, reach, and economic impact.”

NOT CLEAR-CUT
New Jersey’s business interruption bill, a model for others, is stalled while Roy Freiman, the lawmaker who introduced it, waits for an alternative plan from the industry.

“I said, ‘Look, we don’t want insolvency, but surely there is some place between 100% denial and insolvency that you can operate within,’” Freiman told Reuters.

The city council in Washington, DC shelved a similar plan in early May after “pretty intense” lobbying, Council Member Charles Allen, a supporter, told Reuters. APCIA’s cost estimate was cited in council discussions along with an association white paper describing the plan as unconstitutional.

Chairman Phil Mendelson, who introduced the plan, withdrew it after members voiced fears of a lengthy court fight and insurer insolvency.

“Obviously, our concerns were heard,” Sampson told Reuters at the time.

Trade groups say the industry’s stance has deterred many claims.

“Businesses are being told if you file they will probably deny you,” Andrew Rigie, executive director of the New York City Hospitality Alliance, which represents 2,500 bars and restaurants in New York City, told Reuters.

“We’re telling them to seek counsel and be on record filing claims.”

That’s not an option for George Sizemore, owner of Bit of England Darts & Games Shoppe in Virginia Beach.

Sizemore’s insurance agent told him it would be pointless to claim for the $40,000 in revenue he said he lost while his store was shut because his policy does not cover pandemics.

“The only way I could file a claim would be to have a lawyer,” said Sizemore. “I just don’t have the money.”

There are currently dozens of lawsuits in US courts seeking compensation on behalf of small businesses for lost earnings due to the pandemic.

Legal experts said that while many policies exclude pandemics, some do not and there is precedent for courts requiring insurers to pay for physical loss without physical damage, such as when pollution or asbestos make property uninhabitable.

“It’s not anywhere near as clear-cut as the industry says,” said John Ellison, a partner at Reed Smith who has represented policyholders for three decades. — Reuters

India’s first COVID-19 vaccine races to meet mid-August target

INDIA has set an ambitious timeline for its first potential coronavirus vaccine — from human trials to general use in six weeks.

Bharat Biotech International Ltd., an unlisted Indian vaccine maker, received regulatory approval to start human clinical trials for its experimental shot in early July and it already has India’s apex medical research body expediting the process.

The under-development vaccine is “envisaged” to be rolled out “for public health use by Aug. 15 after completion of all clinical trials,” the Indian Council of Medical Research, or ICMR, said in a July 2 letter to clinical trial sites, which was seen by Bloomberg News. It “is one of the top priority projects which is being monitored at the topmost level of the government.”

There’s been no evidence yet that Bharat Biotech’s vaccine is safe for use on humans, not to mention effective. The envisioned timeline is markedly shorter than other front-runner vaccine efforts from American and Chinese drugmakers, most of which started human clinical trials months ago and are now entering the last of three stages of testing.

The bid underscores India’s urgent need for a way to halt the coronavirus. In its letter, ICMR urged the trial sites to enroll volunteers by July 7.

The speediness has alarmed some in the medical fraternity. “Such an accelerated development pathway has not been done EVER for any kind of vaccine, even the ones being tried out in other countries,” Anant Bhan, a medical researcher at India’s Manipal University, said in a Twitter post. “Even with accelerated timelines, this seems rushed and hence, with potential risks.”

After abandoning a costly lockdown that caused tremendous economic suffering without slowing the virus’s spread, Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government is anxious to project control over the outbreak.

The Aug. 15 deadline for Bharat Biotech’s vaccine may reflect that political pressure: that’s the day India celebrates independence from the British, marked by a nationwide address by Modi.

The letter to investigators of clinical trial sites was meant to cut unnecessary red tape, without bypassing any necessary process, and to speed up recruitment of participants, the ICMR said in a statement.

“ICMR’s process is exactly in accordance with the globally accepted norms to fast-track the vaccine development for diseases of pandemic potential wherein human and animal trials can continue in parallel,” according to the statement. “Our trials will be done following the best practices and rigour, and will be reviewed, as required.”

Bharat Biotech plans to enroll 375 people in the first phase of clinical trials and 750 people in the second phase, an ICMR spokesperson said. Whether the vaccine will be approved for general use depends on the outcomes of those trials, he said. A spokeswoman for Bharat Biotech declined to comment on the Aug. 15 timeline in ICMR’s letter.

“They can’t do that,” said Jayaprakash Muliyil, chairman of the Scientific Advisory Committee in National Institute of Epidemiology, referring to the targeted timeline of the vaccine launch. Developing a vaccine is a complicated procedure that involves proving its effectiveness and safety, he said.

While Bharat Biotech’s timeline is ambitious compared to other efforts, India’s mature medical manufacturing sector and its large population, from which human trial volunteers can be easily found, are factors that could help accelerate the usual vaccine development process.

C. Prabhakar Reddy, a professor in Hyderabad’s Nizam’s Institute of Medical Sciences, one of the trial sites that received ICMR’s letter, said: “We are all working day and night to meet the deadline but still it will be neck and neck race,” he said, adding that he doesn’t anticipate any shortage of volunteers “in the current scenario.”

A vaccine ready for public use will allow the safe reopening of schools, offices and factories to revive India’s economy, which is hurtling toward its first contraction in more than four decades. It will also tie in with self-reliance — a motto Modi has repeated often in recent weeks.

Developing nations are eager to pare their dependence on other nations and foreign drugmakers in securing vaccines. Called Covaxin, the “inactivated vaccine” candidate has demonstrated safety and immune response in preclinical studies, Bharat Biotech said in a June 29 statement that cited the firm’s “track record in developing vero cell culture platform technologies.”

It has developed vaccines against polio, rotavirus, Japanese encephalitis and Zika, according to the statement.

Bharat Biotech “is working expeditiously to meet the target, however, final outcome will depend on the cooperation of all the clinical trial sites involved in the project,” the ICMR letter said. — Bloomberg

A momentary farewell to growth: Hope we meet again soon?

By Marvin A. Tort

The reality is that the virus is not going away.

In just about six months, more than 10 million people have been infected by COVID-19 around the world, and more than half a million have died. The number of cases continues to rise globally.

Governments were caught unawares, and many remain at a loss how to contain the virus. States resorted to closing their borders and locking down entire cities. Movement for most was minimized to the barest essentials like buying food and medicine, while economic activity ground to a halt. Bustling urban centers became deserted overnight. The world was closed for business.

“The COVID-19 pandemic pushed economies into the Great Lockdown, which helped contain the virus and save lives, but also triggered the worst recession since the Great Depression,” wrote Gita Gopinath, an International Monetary Fund (IMF) economic counsellor and director of research.

Given the scale and harshness of the resulting downturn, the IMF is already expecting a deep global economic recession in 2020 and a slow recovery in 2021. “This crisis like no other will have a recovery like no other,” added Ms. Gopinath in a recent post on IMFBlog, a forum for IMF staff and officials expressing views on issues of the day.

Debt ratings agency Moody’s Investors Service, in a recent report, said the second quarter of 2020 is shaping up to be “the worst quarter for the global economy since at least World War II.” And while some economies started to reopen in June, and set out on the path to recovery of some sort, “in the absence of a medical solution, the strength of the recovery is highly uncertain and the impact on sectors and countries uneven,” Ms. Gopinath added.

This is particularly true for the Philippines, which in July, the fourth month of the lockdown, continues to report record numbers of new cases daily, having little to show for what was touted as Asia’s earliest and longest lockdown.

For a nation of over 100 million people, the official number of COVID-19 deaths is relatively small. But the pandemic’s economic impact has been devastating. The strictest part of the lockdown, which overlapped with the tail end of the first quarter, ended the economy’s 22-year growth streak.

“The outlook is quite grim, a sharp contraction of 7% this year, with GDP (gross domestic product) not expected to return to 2019 levels earlier than 2022,” according to Romeo Bernardo and Christine Tang in their latest quarterly report for research and consulting group Global Source Partners. Mr. Bernardo was undersecretary at the Department of Finance during the Corazon C. Aquino and Ramos administrations.

“The surprise GDP contraction in Q1, when the domestic economy was seemingly growing robustly at the start of the year and with the quarantine in effect only in the last two weeks of the quarter, points to the high economic cost of the lockdown,” they wrote. “While government is starting to loosen lockdown conditions, we do not see the economy returning to positive growth before 2021, i.e., the recovery in the upcoming quarters will not be as quick nor as sharp as government expects.”

GDP in the first quarter contracted for the first time since 1998. And, after eight years of above-6.0% annual growth until 2019, the economy is now expected to contract in 2020. In the second quarter, as a result of the prolonged lockdown, the economy shed jobs. Unemployment doubled year on year, and is now expected to rise to around 10 million by the end of the year. Hundreds of thousands of overseas Filipino workers have been forced back home by job cuts and border closures.

During the lockdown, some sectors were hit harder than others. Tourism, for instance, is facing a loss of up to $7.7 billion, or 2% of GDP, after being shut down for four months, the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) reported. With another four months of muted activity, the sector can lose up $15.19 billion or 5% of GDP. A full-year shutdown can bring losses up to $22.64 billion or 7% of GDP.

With the wisdom of hindsight, it is easy to question the reasoning behind the prolonged lockdown, considering its economic cost. “Did we flatten the curve, after three months of immobilizing people and the economy?” asked Cielito F. Habito, Socioeconomic Planning Secretary during the Ramos Administration and now a professor of Economics at the Ateneo de Manila University.

“GDP falls for the first time in 22 years, with the worst yet to come,” Mr. Habito noted in a recent presentation to the Institute of Corporate Directors. And the number of COVID-19 cases in the country, particularly in economically-important places like Metro Manila and Cebu, continues to rise.

At this point, “a total write-off of the Philippine economy in 2020 is inevitable,” said Margarito B. Teves, Finance Secretary during the Arroyo administration and among the government economic managers who successfully steered the economy through difficult times when the 2007-2008 global financial crisis hit.

Mr. Teves also told a recent briefing organized by the Wallace Business Forum that if economic activity does not pick up soon, many small businesses could close permanently, poverty could worsen, and more people could end up dying of hunger or poor nutrition than of COVID-19 infection.

But Mr. Teves remains guardedly optimistic. “A low base in 2020 suggests relatively better performance in 2021. COVID-19 was a disruption to an economy that had solid macroeconomic fundamentals and was among the most vibrant economies in the world. So, if COVID is reasonably contained, we could be in a position to recover ahead of others,” he added.

Government economic managers are just as hopeful that the economy can soon begin its gradual recovery, as restrictions on movement and economic activity are eased. Since June 1, many regions have transitioned to looser forms of quarantine, allowing many businesses to resume operations. But a sustainable recovery towards 2021 will depend largely on the government’s ability to pump-prime the economy.

“The outlook for 2021 is based on major assumptions. Number one, we have gradual recovery starting July of this year and the second is that we also see the public sector or the government increasing spending as a stimulus,” Socioeconomic Planning Acting Secretary Karl Kendrick T. Chua told the House Committee on Economic Affairs. “If those two are achieved, then the target is (up to) 9% growth next year.”

Proposed legislation to help revive the economy will go before the 18th Congress, which reopens in late July. These include bills on higher government spending to stimulate the economy, lowering corporate taxes, and granting new tax incentives to investors. A new legal definition for public services is also being proposed to get around constitutional limits on foreign ownership of public utilities, thereby allowing more foreign investment in sectors like telecommunications.

Anticipating loan defaults and a credit crunch, the government also wants to inject P50 billion in additional capital into government banks, so they can lend more to micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs); and the creation of new asset management companies as “special purpose vehicles” to take over the nonperforming loans and assets of private commercial banks, and thus free them up to lend more.

“Over 99%, of Philippine firms are classified as micro-, small- and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs), with their business models dependent on steady monthly cashflows. The unprecedented earnings shock from the prolonged (enhanced community quarantine is expected to push many of the smaller firms into bankruptcy, especially those in the services sector that thrive on face-to-face contact,” Mr. Bernardo and Ms. Tang noted in their report.

“Even among larger firms, which in general can weather the crisis especially under a low interest rate environment, there are pockets of risk from industries directly hit by the crisis (e.g., airlines, hotels) and certain overleveraged corporates that may or may not merit rescue packages. Although there are sectors, e.g., health and telecoms, that will continue to expand to meet higher demand, these will be comparatively few,” they added.

Legislative proposals, which can take three to six months if not longer to pass, are doubly crucial for an economy in the doldrums and a government in dire need of stimulus money. Particularly when you consider that, according to Finance Secretary Carlos G. Dominguez III, there will be no new tax bills on the legislative agenda to be submitted by the Executive to Congress this year.

Mr. Dominguez’s position regarding new taxes puts into question the viability of the proposed Accelerated Recovery and Investments Stimulus for the Economy of the Philippines (ARISE Philippines) bill, which the House of Representatives passed on third reading in June. The bill is estimated to cost P1.3 trillion, but the government can only identify P130 billion worth of available funds from budget savings and realignments, leaving the gap to be filled by borrowing and new taxes.

Legislators that pushed for ARISE wanted to boost the troubled economy through wage subsidies, cash-for-work programs, zero-interest loans for companies, and loan guarantees for banks. But Acting Socioeconomic Planning Secretary Karl Kendrick T. Chua argued that the government would not have the money to fund the proposed stimulus measure unless new tax bills are passed.

Commenting on the various legislative proposals, Mr. Teves, a former legislator who once headed the House Committee on Economic Affairs, said these could give the government “better capacity to mobilize financial resources to stimulate the economy.”

Public Private Partnerships (PPPs) could also be crucial in continuing the Duterte Administration’s Build-Build-Build program “at full throttle,” to make up for having more government resources diverted to anti-COVID measures and assistance to businesses, he added.

“With the economy certain to contract sharply in Q2, the hope is that government intervention could make Q3/Q4 recoveries as strong as possible, not least by boosting consumer and business confidence through a bigger stimulus package. A speedier economic revival, it is argued, would benefit public finances through more favorable debt dynamics that would make the larger budget deficit financeable,” said Mr. Bernardo and Ms. Tang.

“Indeed, fiscal authorities have a tough balancing act ahead, not least because they also need to take spending leakages into account, an issue that is evident in the ongoing slow distribution of cash support. But clearly, what they choose to do — and we think they have room to maneuver — would matter greatly for how well the economy will emerge from this crisis,” the pair added.

Unfortunately for the troubled economy, legislative efforts, and even reviving the PPP for infrastructure projects, will take time. And their positive impact on the economy will take even longer. Meantime, the risk of people getting sick from COVID-19 or forced to stay home will continue to be a drag on labor supply and firm productivity, Mr. Bernardo and Ms. Tang noted.

Consumer and business sentiment will also likely remain low in this environment, while numerous Bangko Sentral rate cuts intended to make more cash available to the economy “will not necessarily push risk averse banks to lend to businesses already teetering between illiquidity and insolvency,” they added.

For Ateneo’s Mr. Habito, economic recovery can be hastened also by government prioritizing assistance to sectors or industries with the most potential to generate jobs and restore income; and, by prioritizing help for regions or provinces or cities that “appear least at risk from the virus spread, and can thus ease up earlier than rest.”

He noted that the sectors of Wholesale and Retail Trade; Agriculture, Hunting and Forestry; and, Construction have been top job creators, accounting for about half of the number of jobs nationwide. As for generating income, the top contributors were Manufacturing; Trade and Repair Services; Real Estate, Renting and Business Activities; and, Other Services.

The problem, however, is that “areas that can most contribute to restoring jobs, production and incomes are also those where it’s most risky to ease up,” Mr. Habito said. He pointed in particular to the National Capital Region, Central and Southern Luzon, Cebu province, and the Davao Region and Southern Mindanao.

Simply put, recovery and growth now depend not only on economic solutions but on medical interventions as well. But a vaccine is still far off, possibly available only by late 2021, and drug treatments are currently in limited supply overseas and remain elusively expensive for a nation with a low per-capita income. At this point, government stimulus efforts, coupled with effective containment at the local level, appear to be the most viable option to curtailing the spread of COVID-19 while slowly easing restrictions on movement, and to increasing economic activity.

As Mr. Bernardo and Ms. Tang noted in their report, improving the economy’s performance in the near term will “rely on government being able to prop up demand by striking the right balance between easing lockdown conditions alongside fiscal support measures, and minimizing any widespread recurrence of infections, which will be invaluable for regaining consumer and investor confidence.”

The caveat, of course, is that allowing the economy to restart remains a risky proposition. The potential for a new wave of infections remains high, especially in densely populated city centers and regions that account for most business operations. “At this time, we cannot rule out a more pessimistic outcome of double-digit GDP contractions, which will happen if a second wave of widespread infections occur necessitating another extensive lockdown,” Mr. Bernardo and Ms. Tang noted.

But, if there are still doubts as to how the government will respond to the COVID-19 slump, Mr. Dominguez offered a pragmatic course of action. In a televised briefing on June 30, he noted that the National Capital Region and its nearby provinces accounted for about two-thirds of the economy’s output. He backs the easiest quarantine restrictions in these areas.

“The reality is… we will have to live with (the virus) for a long time. I really believe we really should begin opening,” Mr. Dominguez was quoted as saying in a news report. “You know, NCR, Calabarzon, that is where the economy is based. About 60% or 67% of our economy is based in that area. (We should move) to MGCQ (modified general community quarantine) as quickly as possible because people have to start working.”